THE LIFE AND TIMES OF MARC ANTHONY

 

CHAPTER XI

Antony's Struggle to Prevent Civil War,

and his Difficulties with Caesar's heir, Octavian.

44 BC

 

Brutus was the only one of the assassins who could, be said to deserve sympathetic consideration, for Antony had now heard of the great mental struggle through which this slow-brained and studious personage had passed, and he could see that the unfortunate man had been actuated by motives as altruistic as they were misguided. When Cassius was first organizing the conspiracy, so Antony was told, it was agreed that Brutus ought to be persuaded to join in the plot for the reason that his acquiescence would give almost a religious sanction to the plan, and therefore the greatest pressure had been brought to bear upon him. In revealing the plot to him, for instance, Cassius had said: “Rome demands from you, Brutus, as an hereditary debt, the extirpation of tyranny”; and thus by approaching him as the genuine descendant of the great Brutus, the liberator of the nation from the rule of its early kings, the conspirators aroused in his heart that bright flame of family pride, which had but flickered within him so long as the stigma of being Caesar’s bastard was upon him.

But after he had entered into the plot, his conscience had given him no peace; and his mind had been so tortured by its silent arguments that sleep had left him, and at last his wife Porcia, Cato’s daughter, had become aware that he was living in the anguish of a terrible secret, and in the end had persuaded him to admit her into it. Thereupon she, too, had been rendered sleepless and distracted, and on the fatal day she had nearly revealed the conspiracy by her hysteria. At the moment of the assassination, in fact, she was in a dead faint.

Antony’s determination to punish the murderers, however, was not influenced by these personal considerations, and he proceeded to bring about their ruin. Caesar’s will was read in his, Antony's, house in the presence of those of the Dictator’s friends and relatives who were available; and, as has already been stated, it was found that he had left a great part of ins fortune to Octavian, and smaller shares to his two other grand-nephews, and that Octavian had been asked to adopt the name of Caesar. In the event of the two above-mentioned grand-nephews dying before him, their portions were to go to that same Decimus Brutus Albinus who had betrayed him, and to Antony—a mark of esteem which the latter must have deeply appreciated and which is yet another indication of his worth.

But the clause in the will which Antony s mind seized upon, and which was obviously his trump-card in the line of action he had decided upon, was that which bequeathed his beautiful gardens beyond the Tiber to the people of Rome as a public park, and a personal gift of three hundred sesterces to every individual in the city—a sum which must have represented several weeks wages to the working man. The size of the gift, however, was not its outstanding feature: the fact which was so valuable to Antony was that Caesar had thereby shown his unfailing love for the People, and that the bequest would establish him in their memory as a loving father, a friend of the poor and the humble.

On the following day, March 20th, the funeral took place—in spite of the passionate protests of Brutus and Cassius, who saw clearly enough that the public cremation of the Dictator would give occasion for a show of sympathy very detrimental to their cause. Antony, however, had been stubbornly determined to do Caesar this honor. He had arranged that the body should be carried in state to the Campus Martius, where a pyre was constructed, close to the tomb of the Dictator’s daughter, Julia, Pompey’s wife; but the earlier ceremonies were to be performed in the Forum, and hither, seething with excitement, the crowds flocked. All day long the musicians played their dirges and solemnly beat their drums, while from time to time actors performed short scenes from classical plays chosen by Antony because of their bitter appropriateness to the occasion, one such being an excerpt from a tragedy by Pacuvius, in which the words “I saved those who have killed me were repeated with telling effect”. 

At nightfall, Antony, magnificent in his Consular robes, made his way to the Forum, determined to arouse the people to a whole­hearted support of the Caesarian party, yet equally determined to prevent any riotous attacks upon the assassins, who had confined themselves to their houses in anticipation of trouble. His purpose—and in it he proved his statesmanship—was to maintain peace in this hour of turmoil, yet to excite indignation against the crime, so that in due course the conspirators might be brought to justice without a fight when Rome was once more tranquil.

On his arrival upon the turbulent scene, in the gathering darkness, the body of the Dictator was taken from its temporary mortuary, and, to the dissonant accompaniment of cries and mournful chanting, was laid upon an ivory bed covered with purple and cloth of gold, this being placed under a gilded catafalque which represented in small size the temple of Venus, Caesar’s divine ancestress. After the religious ceremonies had been performed, during which Antony himself intoned the funeral chant, a herald, instructed by him, recited to the crowd a list of the honors, both human and divine, which the Senate had conferred upon the Dictator, and censoriously repeated the oath so vainly taken by the senators to defend his person with their lives. Antony then mounted the rostra and addressed the now silent multitude in a speech which, though short, was “in every way beautiful and brilliant”, and which was afterwards described by Cicero, who, however, was not present when it was delivered—as a panegyric capable of arousing the most intense emotion. The text of the speech quoted by Appian and Dion Cassius is probably a later elaboration of what he said; but it seems that he referred tenderly to Caesar’s brilliance and goodness of heart, and spoke of the great benefits he had conferred on the people of Rome both in his lifetime and now by the terms of his will.

Then, carried away by his own eloquence and by his very genuine sorrow, he impulsively told his officers to bring him the blood­stained garments of the murdered man which had been exhibited at the head of the bier; and with these in his hands he turned again to his audience, dramatically showing them the rents made by the daggers, and the stains of the blood, the tears running down his face as he struggled to find words by which to vent the torrent of the emotions pent up within him these five days.

It had been arranged that at the end of his oration the funeral procession should set out for the Campus Martius to cremate the body, as the law decreed, outside the city’s walls; but the crowd was so stirred by Antony’s words that, as though the matter had been carried by vote, they determined with one consent to take the proceedings out of the hands of the officials and to cremate the corpse here in the heart of the metropolis. Some shouted out that it should be carried up to the Temple of Jupiter Capitolinus and there burnt in the holy-of-holies, the most sacred spot in Rome, even though in so doing the whole building would probably go up in flames; others declared that it ought to be burnt upon the spot whereon the murder had been committed.

But at length somebody proposed that the cremation should be carried out here in the Forum; and, instantly taking to the suggestion, the crowd seized upon chairs, benches, and any available of woodwork, heaping them up into an enormous pyre, onto which the bier was presently lifted. Lighted torches were applied, and soon the body of the Dictator subsided into the flames, while the sparks shot up into the night, and the smoke rolled like a cloud across the face of the rising moon.

Many persons, moved by the general hysteria, tore off their outer garments and flung them into the blaze; military officers un­buckled their valuable breastplates and cast them upon the pyre; and here and there a weeping woman was seen to throw her jewels into the flames. On all sides people were sobbing passionately, beating their breasts, and wailing the funeral chants; and at length the fierce cry was raised that the houses of the assassins should be attacked and burnt, whereupon, in spite of Antony’s alarmed protests, a rash was made for the pyre, and flaming pieces of wood were carried off by shouting and gesticulating men, who hastened away in the direction of the houses of Brutus, Cassius, and others. “It was you, Antony—you, I say” cried Cicero a few months later, “who let loose those attacks! Abandoned men, slaves for the most part, hurled firebrands into our houses, and we were obliged to repel their onrush by our own unaided exertions; but it was you who set them on!”

Antony was in reality aghast at the emotional outburst his words had caused, which endangered the peace of the city, and he checked the noting with the utmost seventy, giving orders that those caught setting fire to any house should be summarily executed. Brutus, Cassius, and the others no doubt owed their lives to his prompt action; but there was one man at least who was not so fortunate. He was a Tribune of the People, named Cinna; and the mob, confusing him with Caesar’s brother-in-law, Cinna, the praetor, who had lately made some disparaging remarks about Caesar’s moral life, pounced upon him and literally tore him to pieces, finally dancing off with his head stuck upon a spear.

On the following day there was further rioting, and the conspirators were again besieged in their homes, while the miserable Cicero, appalled to find that his ambitions and rash inclinations had led him to identify himself with the losing faction, sat behind the barred doors of his house, listening to the tumult outside and cursing Antony and all his works. Brutus, of course, was in despair. He had expected the majority of the senators and officials to commend the murder; and though a great many of them had certainly done so, and had made possible the technical amnesty which now existed, he had not reckoned with the People. Antony’s speech at the funeral had been fatal to the murderers’ cause; and it seemed likely that the popular party would now oblige them to leave Rome, even, indeed, if it did not exact from them the extreme penalty. Only Antony stood between them and public vengeance; and the question which fevered their minds was whether he, Antony, was strong enough to maintain peace, or whether he would not be more likely to be carried along on the tide of the mob’s excitement; more especially once it was obvious that his own emotions would tend to lead him in that direction.

Dolabella had already fled from the city, having lost his influence with the rabble by his having shown friendliness towards the conspirators; the Senate was divided in its views, and was much too frightened to be of any service to the cause of peace; and Cicero had proved himself to be far from the bold leader of republican thought his writings and his private conversation had led Brutus to expect him to be. The murderers, in fact, had supposed that they would have a solid backing of better-class opinion; they had pictured themselves grouped around the revered figure of Cicero, from whose inspired lips the doctrines for which they stood would pour in acceptable language; and they had supposed that Dolabella would swing the mob over to their side.

But Antony had wrecked their hopes. He had secured a public funeral for Caesar against the opposition of all those who approved of the assassination; he had used the occasion to play upon the emotions of the People; and he had turned to overwhelming account the contents of the Dictator’s will. True, he had managed to maintain order and to effect a sort of compromise during these perilous days—Brutus admitted that they had to thank him for that; but the stupefaction of the whole city had aided him, and now he seemed to be undoing the good work, and allowing the popular hysteria to carry him off his feet.

During the next few days one conspirator after another slipped out of Rome and went into hiding in the country. Albinus, by one of Caesar’s last appointments, had been given the governorship in Cisalpine Gaul; and, since one of Antony’s measures in the emergency had been the ratification of all the Dictator’s decrees, Albinus hastened to his province to take possession of it before his authority was repealed. Tullius Cimber, likewise, hurried off to Bithynia, of which Caesar had made him governor. By the first week in April Cicero, too, had given up all hope of leadership, and had fled in despair to his villa on the Bay of Naples.

Shortly after this, a certain Herophilus, who had been banished from Rome by the Dictator, came back to the capital, and, wishing to gain the favor of the rabble, set up a sacred column on the spot where the body had been cremated, and, by arousing the religious frenzy of those who here made their devotions to Cesar’s divinity, attempted to incite the crowd to further acts of violence against the conspirators, as a result of which Cassius, Brutus, and others were again besieged in their houses, these becoming so many forts each defended by its household against the angry mob. A critical state of affairs developed; but Antony acted with prompt and justifiable severity. He caused Herophilus to be arrested and executed, and thereby saved the city once more from anarchy.

He then authorized Brutus and Cassius to leave Rome, and before the middle of April these two had fled to Lanuvium, a day’s journey to the south. Trebonius followed shortly afterwards, going as governor to the province of Asia Minor, that post having been given him by the man he had helped to assassinate. At the same time the leading members of the Caesarian party also left the metropolis; and sometime in April Queen Cleopatra packed up and set sail for Egypt, taking with her the Dictator’s little son, Caesarion. She must have been a broken-hearted woman; for, whether her expectations were based on fact or not, she had believed that her marriage to Caesar had been imminent and she had never for a moment doubted that she would presently be seated at his side on the throne of an Egypto-Roman kingdom whose bounds would be the ends of the earth. Now, by the daggers of men she had often entertained at her house, her position had been changed in an instant from that of prospective omnipotence to the mere sovereignty of a restless little country across the seas—a sovereignty which a new and unfriendly Roman government might soon send its legions to take from her.

To Antony she must have poured out her troubles, but he could do nothing to help her : she would have to return to Alexandria and bide her time until the Roman situation had clarified; but there can be little doubt that her thoughts, fired by Caesar’s vision of world­wide dominion, must have burnt with the desire to ally herself to whatever new master of Rome the Fates might throw up out of the existing chaos. In her own way she had loved Caesar, but she had loved his dreams still more; and the overthrow of all those splendid hopes which had completely possessed her mind for these last months must have left her more desolate than any words have the power to describe.

Though history is silent upon the subject, it is not credible that she could have gone back to her own country without first having attempted to enlist the good offices of Antony; and it may be supposed that he had promised to do his best to help her to maintain her position at least as sovereign of an independent kingdom. In him she may have already seen the future autocrat of the world; but his authority was by no means unshakably established, nor was he following, even with unsteady tread, in Caesar’s clear footsteps. He had been opposed to the Dictator’s ideas of monarchy, and he had not yet so much as dreamt of aiming, himself, at that royal crown which Caesar’s hands had so nearly grasped. All his energies were directed at present to the sole purpose of maintaining peace under democratic rule in his distracted country, and the highest flights of his imagination carried him no further than the vision of himself as virtual Dictator for the next few years, governing the empire as the successor and representative of the murdered Caesar. Someday, Cleopatra may have told herself, she would whisper into the ear of a new ruler of Rome the suggestion of a world-throne to be shared with her and perhaps to be handed on to Caesarion; but whether or not that man would be Antony she could not yet determine.

It is possible that before she left she gave him money with which to maintain his cause, for he was undoubtedly collecting funds at this time by every means, straight or crooked, and Cicero, a few months later, demanded to know how it came about that Antony, who was heavily in debt on the Ides of March, should have been free of his burdens in April.  “There was nothing in the whole world”, said Cicero, “which anyone wanted to buy that Antony was not ready to sell”; and though this, of course, was an exaggeration, there can be little doubt that the urgent need of money required as urgent a search for it.

King Deiotarus of Galatia and Armenia, a man who had sided with Pompey against Caesar, and had been deprived by the latter of part of his dominions, offered a large sum of money for the restoration of these realms; and Antony very conveniently found amongst Caesar’s papers a memorandum which justified him in acceding to this monarch’s wishes. Many people declared, of course, that it was a forgery; but the fact that Cicero had recently pleaded for Deiotarus in the presence of Caesar, in an eloquent speech—Pro Rege Deiotarowhich is still extant, suggests that the Dictator may well have made a note to this effect.

Antony then produced another document, purporting to be a memorandum of the Dictator’s, which was his authority for giving the rights of citizenship to the Sicilians of course at a price; but here again one may suppose that such an action had been contemplated by Caesar, very possibly at the instance of Cicero, who always had the interests of the Sicilians at heart, and it is well-known that the Dictator had aroused the anger of the conservatives in the past by his wide gifts of Roman citizenship outside Italy. Yet one cannot but suspect that Antony did juggle somewhat with the Dictator’s papers; and the Senate certainly made the proposal that the documents should be placed in the charge of a special commission. Antony, however, was not deterred by the common belief that he was resorting to forgery; and a little later he obtained a sum of money from the Cretans in return for granting them, again on the authority of Caesar, future exemption from taxation. His justification is that he needed funds for the upholding of his authority, and for winning the support, for instance, of Caesar’s veterans; and it is certain that, while helping himself liberally enough in the usual Roman way, he spent the bulk of the money in what he conceived to be the public interest.

Towards the end of April the sessions of the Senate closed for the May vacation, and Antony decided to make a tour of the country south of Rome in order to feel for himself the pulse of the nation, and also to do a little recruiting in a quiet way. Brutus and Cassius had been attempting to undermine the Caesarian cause in that part of Italy, and had been trying to gain the support of those old soldiers settled upon the land, whom Antony now wished to enlist; and Cicero, too, down in the neighborhood of Naples, had lately been venting his disappointment by vilifying both the dead Dictator and Antony. The orator, at this time a sour, grey-haired man of sixty-three, was so embittered by his misfortunes that, while in public he maintained for his own safety a neutrality which included a treacherous show of friendship to Antony, in private he allowed himself to become extremely violent in his attacks upon the Caesarians.

He now spoke of the murder of the Dictator as “the magnificent banquet of the Ides of March”, and regretted that he had not been invited to take part in it; he spoke of Brutus and Cassius as heroes, and of Antony as a drunkard and a reckless gambler; and, to quote a well-known editor of his private correspondence, “he expressed a satisfaction at the assassination, which, after Caesar’s great generosity to him and his profuse, if not servile, acknowledgment of it, is nothing less than ferocious, so that no portion of the whole collection of his letters exhibits his character in so unpleasant a light”. He fretted at the inability of the conspirators to take any action, and to Atticus he wrote, in April, “I fear that the Ides of March have given us nothing beyond the pleasure and the satisfaction of our hatred”. That hatred was intense, and gradually it focused itself wholly upon Antony, the one man who stood like a hulking gladiator in the path of the assassins’ advance.

Antony was able to leave Rome with some easiness of mind because his wife, Fulvia, and his two younger brothers, Lucius and Caius, were there to carry on his work and to keep him in close touch with events. Caius was now Praetor and Lucius a Tribune of the People, both having been given these appointments by Caesar: they were men of no great distinction, but they were useful agents of their brother. Fulvia, too, was in these days an important factor in political life, and many of Antony's measures—for instance, the rehabilitation of King Deiotarus—were thought to have been initiated by her.

Antony’s mother, Julia, was still alive, and, being a member of the family of the Caesars, was probably a strong supporter of a policy of revenge against the assassins, although her brother, Lucius Caesar, was in favor of the Act of Oblivion. Antony’s uncle, Caius Antonius, was also back in Rome now, after nearly fifteen years of exile on the island of Cephalonia, having been pardoned, it would seem, by Caesar; but he could have had little liking for Antony, who had disgraced and divorced his daughter Antonia, it will be re­called, because of her misbehavior with Dolabella. Indeed, Antony must have deeply offended the returned exile; for, a few weeks earlier, in a full meeting of the Senate, at which Caius Antonius was present, Antony had lost his temper with Dolabella, and had publicly branded the fat young man and the unhappy Antonia as adulterer and adulteress. Antony was very liable, always, to lose his temper and to say more than he intended; and, anyhow, he was very sore about this intrigue, for it was a reflection upon his own success as a lover, a matter upon which he prided himself.

His tour of the south was very successful in its purpose, namely that of arousing and recruiting, Caesar’s ex-soldiers, and counteracting the propaganda of the conspirators; but, during the trip, he seems to have combined business with pleasure in a rather unnecessarily reckless way. In spite of the gravity of the situation he gave very gay parties in the cities he visited, and often drank too much. At a charming villa near Casinum (S. Germano) on the inland road to Naples, which had been confiscated from the author, Marcus Varro, on the dubious authority of Caesar’s papers, he entertained a party of guests, who all misbehaved themselves so thoroughly that scandal said the floors were awash with wine, and the place full of the laughter of actresses and prostitutes. At the break-up of this riotous house-party he was carried to the neighboring town of Aquinum dead-drunk; and the inhabitants who had come out to give him an official welcome heard only his snores issuing from behind the closed curtains of his litter. Reaction from the strain of the terrible days through which he had passed, and freedom from the controlling hand of Fulvia, had evidently been too much for him.

While he was on his way back to Rome, bringing with him a whole army of Caesar’s veterans, news was suddenly brought to him that Dolabella had come out of hiding, and, declaring that he was joint-Consul with Antony, had ordered the destruction of the sacred column set up by the late Herophilus on the spot where the Dictator had been murdered, was inciting the crowd against the Caesarians, and was being hailed with acclamation by the senators who favored the conspirators. Antony’s brother Lucius had come to verbal blows with the young man; and the city, it was said, was once more in an uproar, the conservative element rallying round Dolabella, as though he were the hoped-for savior of their cause. Upon hearing these tidings Antony was so stunned that he was afterwards said by eye-witnesses to have fainted dead away, though it is more probable that he merely rested his befuddled head against the nearest support, and shut his eyes in an effort to gather his wits.

Thereafter, he hastened to Rome, arriving towards the end of May, and thoroughly scaring his opponents by marching the ex-soldiers through the streets with drawn swords, their shields and baggage bumping along behind them upon carts. But the whole face of the situation was changed by the news which awaited him: Octavian, Caesar’s grand-nephew and heir, had come to Rome, had claimed his heritage, and had taken the name of Caesar.

Octavian had been at Apollonia when he received the news of the Dictator’s death, and a few days later he had crossed the Adriatic back to Italy, where, on disembarking, he heard for the first time of the contents of the Dictator’s will. He then made his way quietly to Naples, which he reached on April 18th, and thence went straight to his home, the house of his stepfather, Philippus, not far away. Philippus was a cautious man, and strongly advised Octavian not to claim so dangerous an inheritance, especially since he was only eighteen years of age. At present, he said, it was doubtful which side would finally gain the upper hand; and in the event of the conspirators obtaining control, Octavian’s life would not be worth very much if he were known to be putting himself forward as Caesar’s successor.

Philippus suggested a visit to Cicero, who lived quite close, and who, superficially, was neutral; and Octavian therefore went over to see the two-faced old orator, and made himself as agreeable as he could, not knowing that Cicero was at this very time privately expressing his savage approval of the Dictator’s murder. Octavian wanted to adopt the name “Caesar” at once, in accordance with his great-uncle’s wishes; but Cicero advised him not to do this, and so did Philippus. The boy then startled them by announcing that he was presently going on to the capital to see his mother, Atia, who was still at her town-house in Rome; and not long afterwards he made the journey there with so little ostentation that Antony, who, of course, was informed of his movements, did not think the youth was worth worrying about. It was only when he got back to Rome that he was told how the daring youngster had proclaimed himself Caesar’s successor. 

Octavian certainly did not lack courage, and in spite of his being a poor specimen of manhood, unhealthy, spotty, and somewhat effeminate in manner, he was unusually active both in mind and body, being a keen football-player, so long as he did not have to play in the sun, which hurt his eyes and made him sneeze and keeping himself fit by long evening walks and runs. He belonged very decidedly to Rome’s fashionable young intellectuals, spoke Greek fluently, tried his hand at writing plays and poems, and, like the members of the modernist movement today, cultivated an easy vernacular style free from the sort of grandiloquence that Antony loved. He dressed untidily, allowed his fair, yellowish hair to fall into its natural waves without care, and was erratic about his meals, having a poor appetite and little sense of time. He had superb confidence in himself, was callous and inclined to be cruel, and, at this period of his life, was devoid of sex morality, being unpleasantly familiar both with men and women.

Antony had only met him occasionally, and had never regarded him as a serious factor in the situation; but now the stories he heard about him were not a little alarming. Caius Antonius, the Praetor, reported that the young man had come to him at a public meeting, and, having asked to address the people, had promised the crowd that he himself would be responsible for the payment of the three-hundred sesterces to every townsman. Lucius Antonius, the Tribune, reported, likewise, that Octavian had addressed the Comities making the same promise, and uttering a bold and sincere panegyric upon the dead Dictator which had been much resented by Dolabella. Just before Antony’s return, moreover, Octavian had almost caused a riot at a public function by asking to have Caesar’s golden throne brought out, this being refused by some of the republican Tribunes amidst the loud applause of the senators.

The situation was almost ludicrously triangular. Antony, up­holding the democratic cause in the name of the murdered Dictator, was aiming at the future discomfiture of the assassins and their conservative sympathizers so soon as the immediate danger to the nation’s peace was averted; and he was bent on retaining the supreme power in his own hands as the late Caesar’s friend, Consular colleague, and trustee. He was in possession of the dead man’s papers, personal valuables, and so much of his fortune, outside the share bequeathed to Octavian and his cousins, as could be realized; and Calpurnia, the widow, and most of Caesar’s relatives, regarded him as the guardian of their rights.

Dolabella, Antony’s personal enemy, represented the other faction, and had now been confirmed by them in his office as joint-Consul, and was doing his best to have the conspirators restored to public favor. And now into these troubled waters this boy, Octavian, had come fishing, and would soon be asking Antony to hand over Caesar’s remaining money so that the bequests might be paid. Octavian, it was true, was rich enough to pay the legacies out of his own fortune, for his grandfather had been a millionaire money-lender; but it was not to be expected that he would thus impoverish himself.

Antony’s policy was clear: much as it went against the grain, he would have to patch up his quarrel with Dolabella, and attempt to regain that position of impartiality which he had held in the first days after the assassination. The audacious Octavian would have to be squeezed out: there was no room for him in Rome.

A few days later Antony received from the young Caesar a request for an interview, and, in a very bad temper, told him to come to his house—that same house which had once belonged to Pompey. There he purposely kept him waiting in the anteroom for a long time, and at last, ordering him to be ushered in, asked him how he was and what brought him to Rome; but before Octavian had fully stated his purpose, which was to see to the carrying out of the terms of Caesar’s will, Antony cut him short with an uncomfortable laugh, and asked him somewhat blusteringly how at his age he dared to take up the responsibilities of this heritage, when, as he could see for himself, grown men who were tried in battle and were used to politics needed all their courage and their experience to cope with the dangerous situation. He advised the young man to settle his business and get out of Rome as quickly as possible—before Dolabella, or somebody, murdered him, I dare say he said; and, giving him a patronizing pat on the shoulder, he hurriedly dismissed him before anything could be discussed.

The interview brought into Antony’s puzzled mind the consciousness that Caesar had known what he was about when he had made Octavian his heir. This was no ordinary youth: he had rattier a sinister character and an opinion of himself which was disconcerting. The impression he left on the elder man was unpleasant, and Antony seems to have had the feeling that his own game of bluff, his attempt to scare his youthful visitor, had been a mistake. He ought to have overlooked his age, and to have bargained with him as with a man of affairs.

The next few days showed him clearly his error. It was reported to him that Octavian was openly accusing him of having betrayed the memory of Caesar by taking no steps against his murderers and by allowing the amnesty—Cicero’s famous Act of Oblivion—to remain in force. The young man had gathered a group of supporters around him, and was making violent speeches to the mob, urging them to take vengeance on the conspirators and to brush Antony aside as one who was too lukewarm to be their leader. He was declaring that he alone had the right to act in Caesar’s name, and he was telling the delighted crowds that he was prepared to sell everything he had to pay them the Dictator’s bequest, which was being withheld from them only by Antony’s mishandling of Caesar’s fortune. Caesar had been the People’s friend, but Antony was their enemy: he was a traitor, willing to hobnob with the assassins so that by a compromise he might keep the power in his own hands.

Antony was startled, and he at once counter-attacked by taking steps to prevent the ratification of Octavian’s adoption into the family of the Caesars when the measure should come before the Senate. At the same time he sent for Dolabella, and suggested that in the face of the common enemy they should compose their differences and work together. After all, I suppose he argued, Dolabella had once been Caesar’s devoted friend, and it was only because the Dictator, in the last months of his life, had slighted him that this quarrel had arisen which had led Dolabella now to throw in his lot with the conspirators. But had not Caesar also quarreled with Antony himself? They both knew what sort of man Caesar had been, and how he: had dropped his friends mercilessly when they stood in the way of his schemes; yet who could fail to admire him, and, now that he was dead, what use was there in taking vengeance upon his memory? Dolabella and Antony, as the two Consuls, ought to work together for peace, and for the maintenance of that amnesty which alone at present could secure it; and they should both do their utmost to suppress this youth who was trying to throw the whole nation into confusion.

Dolabella was a man without scruples, and he seized the opportunity of striking a bargain with Antony. His terms were quite concrete: he said that at the end of his Consulship he wanted to be made governor of Syria the province promised to Cassius—for a period of five years, so that, if circumstances should permit, he might lead an expedition against Parthia and thereby gain wealth and renown; and meanwhile he wanted a sum of money down. Antony agreed to the terms, and thereupon Dolabella returned to his Caesarian allegiance, never again giving Antony any cause for anxiety about him.

The next thing to do was to reorganize the Democratic Party, and to draft as many loyal partisans as possible into the Senate. At the same time the sympathies of the left wing were enlisted again by the framing of a new land law through the agency of Lucius Antonius: its details are not known, but in general it was a socialistic measure, something in the nature of the law put forward by the Gracchi, and it involved the setting up of a commission with power to buy land and to distribute it, together with some of the public domains, amongst the needy.

Octavian retaliated by making overtures to the conservatives or republicans; and the conspirators, seeing their opportunity, thereupon approached the young man and urged him to join forces with them against their common enemy, Antony. They tried to persuade him that although they had assassinated the Dictator, and although he, as Caesar’s heir, had cause to regard them as family enemies, nevertheless he and they had more in common than had he and the democrats. They asked him to try to forget the murder and to unite with them against Antony’s party; and Octavian, in view of the dangers of his position, readily agreed to make this unholy alliance. It was a bewildering and ludicrous volte-face, and oblige him to show open friendship to those very men upon whom he had so recently demanded vengeance. But he was not embarrassed, at this period of his life, by any high principles, and his quarrel with Antony guided his actions with a far more compelling hand than that of his duty to the Dictator’s memory. 

Cicero and the conspirators—Brutus, Cassius, and all the others who had not left Italy—were now convinced that Antony intended to repeal the Act of Oblivion and set the law in motion against them as soon as circumstances should permit; and they were eager, therefore, to discredit him. Indeed, they heartily wished that they had killed him when they had killed Caesar. It was owing to him that their cause was in such bad shape, and they were constantly blaming one another for having spared his life on the Ides of March. One hopeful sign, however, had revealed itself, namely that Albinus, who had hurried from Rome to take up the governorship of Cisalpine Gaul, had reported that the legions there had accepted him in spite of his being one of the murderers of Caesar. Another point in their favor was that Caesar’s Parthian expeditionary force which had seen a good deal of Octavian when he was with them at Apollonia, where they still were stationed, had tentatively offered us loyalty to him in his trouble with Antony, and might now follow his lead in making friends with the republican party.

But in spite of these reassuring signs they were depressed and anxious, and Cicero himself, who was always either in the heights or the depths, was at present in the abyss of despair. He did not realize, however, that Dolabella had wholly deserted them, and when it became known that the province of Syria had fallen to him, Cicero offered to go there with him as his chief-of-staff. The suggestion fell through, however, and the orator then began to consider the expediency of a private journey into Greece, his object being to retire from Italy until the troubles had blown over. His nerves had gone to pieces, and he longed for the quiet of some Greek retreat, where, amongst the philosophers, he might finish the charming book he was writing on the subject of Old Age. Moreover, he was at this time weighed down with debt, for he always kept up a style of living far beyond his means; and he longed to escape the increasing attentions of his creditors. After much hesitation he sailed for Greece early in August, telling his friends that he was going to see the Olympic Games.

Meanwhile in Rome Octavian’s mother, Atia, spread a curious story in support of her son’s position as Caesar’s sole representative. She said that before he was born, she fell asleep one day in the temple of Apollo, and dreamt that that deity in the form of a fascinating serpent had caused her to be unfaithful to her nuptial vow and had afterwards carried her procreative organs up to heaven to be blessed. That same day, moreover, her husband had the startling dream that the sun had risen from out of her midst, as though she were a range of mountains lying along the eastern horizon. This tale was passed around the city to the accompaniment of appreciative nods and exclamations, and it greatly increased the young man’s prestige. He was given an ovation by the crowd at the public games in July; and when it so chanced that a comet was seen in the evening sky, and the quick-thinking Octavian had declared that it was assuredly the soul of Caesar flying to heaven, the enthusiasm was intense. Octavian then caused a statue of Caesar to be placed in the Temple of Venus, with a golden star above its head—much to the annoyance of Antony, who felt that by such actions the objectionable youngster was stealing his thunder.

To add to his troubles Antony was now having difficulty in dealing with Brutus and Cassius whose continued presence in Italy was a very disturbing influence upon the public mind. He proposed therefore that they should be sent abroad to supervise the purchase of foreign corn, a mission which it was the custom to place in the hands of men of standing. Brutus and Cassius, however, did not care to be thus disposed of: they had many friends in the Senate, and they were ever hoping that the republican party would become strong enough to effect their entire rehabilitation.

At length Antony sent them peremptory orders to undertake this mission, and in a letter to him dated August 4th they replied in a tone which revealed their sullen and unbending attitude. “We have read your letter”, they wrote, “which is insulting, intimidating, and in every way an improper one for you to have written to us ... Our personal sentiments are these. We are anxious to see you held in dignity and honor if it be in a free Republic. We do not invite your antagonism, but, nevertheless, we value our liberty of action more than your friendship. You should therefore consider again and again what you are doing, and what your power is able to accomplish; and be sure you bear in mind not how long Caesar lived, but how short a time he was able to behave like a king”.

This last remark was intended as a warning to Antony not to attempt to play the autocrat; and the letter in general had the effect of making him reconsider the matter of the corn-buying mission, for he was not yet ready to come to blows with the conspirators: the danger from Octavian was too much of a menace to his own position to permit him to think of himself as all-powerful. Octavian was his most serious enemy; and his quarrel with this youth seemed likely to wreck all his plans. His friends were constantly telling him to beware of his young rival; but the more they did so the angrier he became.

At length Caesar’s old soldiers made up their minds to oblige him and Octavian to compose their differences and work together for the good of the State; and they therefore marched in a body to Octavian’s house. The young man thought that his last hour was come when he saw this army approaching, and, having shouted orders for the gates and doors to be bolted, he fled to the roof. But when, to his great relief, he heard the soldiers cheering him, he crept downstairs again and presently received the leaders of the demonstration, who told him in no ambiguous terms that he and Antony had got to shake hands.

The soldiers, it seems, then marched to Antony’s house, who doubtless fled, likewise, to the roof or the cellar, so uncertain was the temper of the populace, and so prepared had he to be at all times to save his skin. It was a nerve-racking life. When he understood their purpose, however, he sullenly consented to meet Octavian; and amidst the cheers of the veterans he and his embarrassingly young rival exchanged visits and agreed to work in harmony.

At about the same time Antony came to an agreement with Dolabella—in their capacity as fellow-Consuls—in regard to the distribution of provincial governorships at the end of the present year, 44 BC, or earlier, if necessary. Dolabella, as has already been said, was to have Syria for five years, and was to be permitted to set out for that province in the early autumn. Antony chose for himself Caesar s old province of Cisalpine Gaul—northern Italy, that is to say—it being so close to Rome; and it was arranged that Albinus, who was already there, should be transferred to Macedonia, while the troops then in the latter country should be transferred to Cisalpine Gaul to serve under Antony who proposed to hold that governorship, likewise, for a period of five years. Brutus was to be got rid of by being given the governorship of the island of Crete; and Cassius was to be sent off as governor, it would seem, of Cyrene.

Now it so happened that Cicero’s voyage to Greece had been, delayed by storms, and at length, after a bad tossing at sea, his ship had been driven back to the Italian coast, where several days were passed in port waiting for better conditions and a favorable wind. Here, however, he received news from his friends that the Senate had been convened for September 1st, and that there was hope then of gathering so strong a body of senators of republican views that Antony’s plans might be brought to nothing. A copy of the letter of Brutus and Cassius to Antony was also shown to him, and he was told that Antony had seemed to take it so to heart that he was likely to abandon his pugnacious attitude and to aim at some sort of compromise. Moreover, Cicero was informed that his departure for Greece had been regarded as a sign of cowardice, and that he was thought to have but repeated his unfortunate flight of fourteen years earlier when his behavior in regard to the Catilinarian conspirators had made him dangerously unpopular. Even his friend Atticus wrote to him in bitter sarcasm, saying, “Very well, then, go, and desert your country: it is quite right in the man who said he was not afraid to die for the fatherland!”

After renewed hesitation and indecision, therefore, he made up his mind to abandon his journey, and to return to Rome for the purpose of encouraging his party at this moment when Antony seemed to be amenable, and also in order to attempt to detach Octavian from his new alliance. It was a bold step; but he had been stung by the imputation of cowardice, and for once in his vacillating career—and this, indeed, was one of the great moments of his life—he rose to the occasion with a courage which goes far to outweigh his former weakness in history’s estimation of his character.

“I see”, he had already written to Atticus, “that I shall run some risks, but I cannot help thinking that it may lie in my power to do some good for the State”. When he was warned that Antony might force him into subserviency, he replied, “I know a better way than that”—meaning suicide; and when it was pointed out that he might be driven into exile he answered, significantly, “I look to another haven which lies handier to my time of life: all I wish is that I may reach it leaving Brutus in prosperity and the Republic re-established”. It is hardly to be supposed, of course, that he seriously contemplated suicide that sequel of political defeat which Roman thought had made customary, for there was considerable reason for hope that his party would come successfully through this period of its difficulties; yet the risk of disaster in some form was present, and his fine words had a closer relation to actuality than was usual with him.

He arrived back in Rome on the last day of August and Antony was irritated to find that he received a great welcome from the conservative party, and that Octavian, too, paid his respects to him. The Senate, however, was to meet next morning, September 1st, and Antony determined to snub the interfering old orator on that occasion by putting forward various measures adverse to the conspirators interests which the senators, he believed, would be obliged to pass. One of these—a measure likely to delight the crowd was the proposal that public prayers and supplications should be made to the spirit of Caesar as to the immortal gods, for the Senate had already, before the assassination, acknowledged his divinity, and the senators could hardly go back now on their former admission, much as many of them might wish to do so. It gave Antony the greatest pleasure to contemplate the discomfiture of Cicero, who would of course be present in the Senate on the morrow, and would have either to acquiesce in this measure or to oppose it publicly, in which latter case the mob would be at his throat. It was a clever trap laid for him, and Antony looked forward with enjoyment to the hour when it would be sprung.

But Cicero was not so easily caught. On his arrival at his house his friends warned him of Antony’s plans, and a hasty conference of the conservative party led to the decision that Cicero and the majority of his colleagues should refrain from attending the sitting of the Senate. Next day, therefore, most of the senatorial chairs were unoccupied, and a note was received from Cicero saying that owing to the fatigues of his journey he was confined to his bed.

Antony was furious, and his anger was increased when the rumor reached him that Cicero had refused to come because he feared that violence would be done to him by the Consul’s soldiers. In a passion of rage and disappointment he addressed the nearly empty House, saying that this rumor was a dastardly slander and belief in it an insult. The conservative senators, he declared, had placed an unbearable slight upon him and the Senate by absenting themselves at this opening meeting of the new session; and he would not tolerate it. He would use all his Consular powers to oblige Cicero to come; and therewith he gave orders that locksmiths and masons should be sent at once to the orator’s home to break open its doors, while soldiers should bring him by force, or, failing to find him, should burn his house to the ground.

The senators were shocked and frightened, and begged him to calm himself; and at length Antony cooled down sufficiently to countermand these wild orders, and to accept sureties for the orator’s good behavior. But he declared that he would never forgive him; and, indeed, all men realized that day that the quarrel between the Caesarian democrats and the anti-Caesarian republicans had entered upon its crisis.

The issue was clear: on the one side was Antony the representative and would-be preserver of the dead Dictator’s absolutism, the defender of that paradox—a democratic autocracy, and with him the unwilling Octavian, forced now to play second-fiddle; on the other side were the conservatives and the conspirators, led by Cicero, representing the old republican ideals and bent upon the recognition of Caesar as a tyrant justly slain. Antony stood for the rescinding of the Act of Oblivion so soon as public calm could be established; Cicero stood for the maintenance of that amnesty. Antony had the People solidly behind him so long as their sympathies were not divided by any disagreement between him and Octavian in the matter of leadership; Cicero was sure of the support of the conservative upper classes.

It was to be a fight now to a finish between the republicans and the democrats. Antony’s blood was up, and he guessed that Cicero, usually so cautious, was in a similar state of ebullience; but in Octavian lay the danger. How long would that pale-faced and sinister young man consent to occupy a back seat?

 

CHAPTER XII

Antony’s Departure from Rome where Cicero was Delivering the Philippic Orations Against Him and his Failure to Wrest Cisalpine Gaul from Albinus.

44-43 BC.