| CRISTO RAUL.ORG ' | 
|  | THE UNIVERSAL HISTORY OF CHRISTIANITY |  | 
| FROM JUSTINIAN TO LUTHER. AD 518-1517CHAPTER VFROM CLOVIS TO CHARLEMAGNE
 CLOVIS, KING OF THE FRANKS 
         THE baptism of Clovis was as significant as the conversion of
        
        Constantine. It was an event which influenced the history of the world.
         In the country which is now France, three races of invaders had fixed
        
        themselves by the end of the fifth century: the Visigoths in the south-west,
        
        their kinsmen the Burgundians in the south-east, the
        
        Franks in the north. The two former races had embraced Arianism, worshipping
        
        Christ as a mere demigod; the Franks were still worshippers of the old German
        
        deities.
         These Franks were divided into two principal groups, the Ripuarians, who dwelt on the bank of the Rhine, and the Salians, who lived near the Issel or Sala. When the Roman Empire fell into pieces, in
        
        476, the chief of the main body of the Salians was Childeric the son of Merovech.
        
        His people lived about Tournai and his warriors
        
        probably numbered about six thousand. He died in 481 and his successor was a
        
        boy of fifteen years, Clovis (Clodowech), the true
        
        founder of the Frankish monarchy. He began his career of success by conquering Syagrius, a Roman general who had carved out for himself a
        
        principality in and around Soissons, and posed as 'King of the Romans'. Clovis
        
        annexed this realm and the population of Gallo-Romans lived on good terms with
        
        their Teutonic conquerors. About 492 he formed a desire to marry Clothilde, a daughter of the king of the Burgundians and a Catholic. A most romantic story of the
        
        wooing of Clothilde is told by the so-called Fredegarius, who lived early in the seventh century and
        
        probably derived his story from old traditions of some value. The union took
        
        place and realized the hopes of the episcopate of Gaul and especially of St. Remi (Remigius) of Reims. But
        
        Clovis remained a pagan, and reproached the wife whom he loved when their first
        
        child died while still wearing his white baptismal robe. The child, he said,
        
        would have lived if he had been baptized in the name of his father's gods. But
        
        the brave queen “thanked God because He had taken her first-born child into His
        
        kingdom”.
         A second child was baptized, sickened, but survived. Clovis nevertheless
        
        did not abandon Thor and Odin. But in 496 he had to face an invasion of the Alemanni, who pressed across the Rhine and occupied the
        
        country between the Rhine and the Vosges mountains. Clovis met them with his
        
        army, and all seemed lost when he implored the aid of Christ and vowed that if
        
        he won the victory he would be baptized. The king of the Alemanni fell and his army was defeated. And on Christmas Day 496, amid a splendor
        
        worthy of the occasion, Clovis was baptized at Reims by St. Remi,
        
        who is said to have uttered the words, “Bow thy neck, 0 Frank, worship what
        
        thou hast burnt, and burn what thou hast worshipped”.
         The news of this conversion sent a thrill through western Christendom,
        
        and the orthodox outside his dominions looked to Clovis to deliver them from
        
        their Arian rulers. His attack on Burgundy was a failure. But in 507 he routed
        
        the Visigoths about ten miles from Poitiers, slaying the mighty Alaric in
        
        single combat, and occupied Bordeaux and Toulouse. He
        
        won four-fifths of Gaul, and in 510, in the great basilica of Tours, he was invested with the tunic, the purple mantle,
        
        and the diadem. The next year he died. He was no saint, but he was not
        
        insincere; and we can well believe the tale told by Fredegarius that Clovis was so moved by the story of Christ's Passion that he exclaimed,
        
        “If I had been there with my Franks, I would have avenged His wrongs”.
         It is St. Gregory of Tours (d. 594) who, in his History of the Franks, and his record of saintly lives, makes the
        
        France of the sixth century live once more. It was an age of cruelty, of
        
        cupidity, and of superstition. But those who pierce through the dull records of
        
        somber crimes and trivial miracles can discover not only romance but also true
        
        religion. The Christians were surrounded by heathen neighbors and their
        
        Christianity was crude and adulterated. But they believed in the presence and
        
        power of God and in the friendship of His saints; they were impressed by the
        
        self-renunciation of lonely hermits and of wealthy men and women who bestowed
        
        all their goods to feed the poor; they could honor a chastity preserved amid
        
        the fires of temptation. The lives of the common people were sad and sordid;
        
        but their religion led them into a happier country, and the worship of the
        
        Church gave them visions of peace and beauty. And
        
        Gregory himself, though he regrets the rusticity of his Latin, was a master of
        
        the art of narrative, able to write just what he had seen and heard. He can
        
        describe the crowds that thronged the roads to a festival, or the hermit in his
        
        lonely cave in the primeval forest, or the mysterious lights that hovered over
        
        the forgotten tombs of saints and martyrs, or his own debate with an Arian
        
        legate from the Visigothic court in Spain.
         After the victories of Clovis, Arianism disappeared from Gaul except in
        
        the south-eastern corner. In Africa the Vandal laws were specially directed
        
        against the Romans and the Catholics; but the persecution, sometimes very
        
        severe, varied according to the temper of the different rulers and the state of
        
        foreign politics. The Vandal Empire was finally crushed by Justinian’s general
        
        Belisarius in 533. The Visigoths in Spain were fierce persecutors, but the
        
        conversion of King Reccared the Visigoth to
        
        Catholicism in 589 secured the ascendancy of Catholicism. Near the close of the
        
        fifth century it seemed as if the whole of the Teutonic world would be Arian,
        
        worshipping a Christ robbed of His eternity. One hundred years later Arianism
        
        was vanishing like an evil dream, and it disappeared when the Lombards of Pavia renounced it in the middle of the seventh
        
        century.
         The Church of Spain, with the aid of the Visigoth kings, acquired a
        
        compact and vigorous organization. It enjoyed a provincial and inter-provincial
        
        system of government under the Bishop of Toledo, 'metropolitan bishop of the
        
        royal city'. It was he, and not the Pope, who had the recognized right to
        
        intervene in the nomination of every bishop in the kingdom. Spain had its own
        
        canon law and its own elaborate liturgy, which was generally abandoned in the
        
        eleventh century, but still survives in a chapel of the cathedral of Toledo. The
        
        Church was almost entirely autonomous, and in 636 Eugenius,
        
        Metropolitan of Toledo, said that he could find in the New Testament no ground
        
        for supposing that St. Peter possessed any unique authority. The Church of
        
        Spain was shattered by the Muslim invasions of the next century.
         While the conversion of the Franks to Catholic Christianity prepared for
        
        the extinction of Arianism, the conversion of the Anglo-Saxons supplied the
        
        Teutonic races with Catholic missionaries of apostolic zeal. When we think of
        
        the work accomplished by the missionaries of the seventh and eighth centuries,
        
        we must bear in mind that the Slavs had submerged the country east of the Elbe,
        
        and that west of that river there were continual wanderings and wars of the
        
        great Teutonic tribes. The Frisians, who in race and language are akin to the
        
        purest English, occupied the greater part of Holland and the adjacent coasts,
        
        extending from Ostend to the river Ems. South of Slesvig a large area was occupied by the Saxons. Their neighbors the Franks had poured
        
        southwards, conquering the Romanized Celts in the country to which they gave
        
        the name of France, and pushing against the Frisians in the north, as well as
        
        the Saxons to the east and the Thuringians beyond the
        
        Saxons. In the seventh century these three latter races were pagan; whereas the Alemanni, whose name became applied to all German
        
        people by the French of later times, were already accepting Christianity from
        
        the Franks.
         
 THE MEROVINGIANS
         We saw that Clovis died in 511. His sons extended their rule over nearly
        
        the whole of Gaul. They subdued the kingdom of Burgundy and they got back from
        
        the Ostrogoths Provence with its famous capital
        
        Arles, 'little Rome in Gaul', still famous for its Roman antiquities and the
        
        classic features of its inhabitants. The Frankish realm tended to fall into
        
        three, and then into two, well-marked divisions. The practice of dividing the
        
        kingdom prevailed for several generations, each death of a king involved a new
        
        partition, and the king of each division was called 'King of the Franks'. The
        
        three divisions were Austrasia, 'the Eastern land', Neustria, 'the Newest
        
        land', and Burgundy, which was often ruled by the King of Neustria. The
        
        principal town of Austrasia, the eastern part of the Frankish kingdom, was
        
        Metz; and the principal town of Neustria, the western part, was Paris, which
        
        had been sagaciously selected by Clovis as his centre.
         Until the death of Dagobert, in 639, the kings
        
        of the Merovingian dynasty displayed considerable energy and variety of
        
        interests. Their inherited love of fighting found an outlet in battles at home
        
        or abroad. And their newly acquired culture expressed itself in the building of
        
        villas, and in the efforts of King Chilperic to
        
        enforce the addition of four new letters to the Latin alphabet invented by his
        
        own royal hand. After Dagobert the Merovingian kings
        
        were neither warriors nor men. They were debauched youths who lolled in their
        
        palaces, took the air in litters drawn by oxen, and met with the early death
        
        that was merited by their vices. It was therefore inevitable that local
        
        officials should try to usurp the royal prerogatives, and that the substance of
        
        royal power should be grasped by the 'Mayors of the Palace'. Such was the
        
        origin of the new dynasty which derived its name of Carolingian from
        
        Charlemagne, its most famous scion.
         Dagobert in his
        
        youth was under the guardianship of Arnulf, Bishop of
        
        Metz, and Pepin I, called 'of Landen', mayor of the
        
        palace of Austrasia (d. 640). Pepin’s daughter
        
        married a son of Arnulf. Their son Pepin II, called
        
        'of Heristal', secured complete predominance in
        
        Austrasia, defeated the Neustrians in 687, and
        
        thereby became in fact, if not in name, sole master of almost the whole of
        
        Gaul. He fought against the Frisians, the Alemanni,
        
        and the Bavarians, and died in 714. He was succeeded by his illegitimate son
        
        Charles Mattel (d. 741), who seized the mayoralty in both kingdoms. Charles
        
        divided his realm between his two sons, giving the east to Carloman and the west to Pepin III, called 'the Short' (d. 768), a monarch no less
        
        important in ecclesiastical history than was his father.
         So much at least seems necessary as a preliminary to
        
        an account of the united work of the English and the Franks in promoting the
        
        knowledge of the Gospel.
                 St. WILIBRORD
         Willibrord (d.
        
        739), an Anglo-Saxon, first established Christianity firmly among the Frisians.
        
        He was the son of Wilgils, a Northumbrian, and was
        
        educated in Wilfrid’s monastery at Ripon. When he was
        
        twenty he went to study in Ireland, and thus he became trained in the two
        
        distinct types of Western Catholicism, the Celtic and the Roman. In 690 he was
        
        sent by St. Egbert, a famous Northumbrian ascetic, with eleven companions, to Frisia. Like his three predecessors among the Frisians, Amandus, Eligius, and Wilfrid, he had to contend with many difficulties. The Frisians
        
        were struggling for their national existence against the Christian Franks, and Rathbod, their king, was a hardened pagan. Failing to
        
        convert the subjects of Rathbod, the Anglo-Saxon
        
        missionary went to the Frank, Pepin II, and preached in the Meuse districts to
        
        the conquered Frisians. He went to Rome and obtained the approval of Pope
        
        Sergius I for his work. He went to Heligoland, where
        
        the native population still retains its Frisian tongue, and there he violated
        
        the heathen sacred places. For this he was brought before Rathbod,
        
        who was so much impressed by Willibrord’s courage
        
        that he spared his life. Once more, at great peril, he destroyed the famous
        
        idol of Walcheren.
         In 695 he again visited Rome, and Pope Sergius consecrated him as
        
        archbishop of the Frisians. Pepin II assigned him Utrecht as his Episcopal
        
        city, and he consecrated bishops and built churches and monasteries. He was
        
        visited by Wilfrid about 703. He was also honored by Pepin’s successor, Charles Martel, who proved himself to be the champion of Christendom by defeating the
        
        Arabs at Poitiers, and thereby saving France, and eventually Europe, from the
        
        domination of the Crescent (732). Willibrord died in
        
        739 at Echternach, one of the monasteries which he
        
        had founded near Trier.
         St. WYNFRITH
         Wynfrith (680-754),
        
        another Anglo-Saxon, is the saint who has the greatest right to be called the
        
        apostle of the Germans. He was born at Crediton, and
        
        educated first at Exeter and then at the monastery of Nursling near Winchester.
        
        He went to Friesland in 716, but as the redoutable Rathbod was then fighting against Charles Martel, it was
        
        hopeless to attempt much for the conversion of Rathbods people. He went back to Nursling, and then proceeded to Rome with a letter of
        
        introduction from the Bishop of Winchester. Pope Gregory II received him
        
        favorably and gave him authority to evangelize Germany. Then with the new name
        
        of Boniface I he went through Bavaria and Thuringia, and when Rathbod died, in 719, he worked for three years in Frisia. Then he went to Hesse and
        
        converted many of the heathen in Amoeneburg. He made
        
        a second journey to Rome and in 722 was consecrated bishop by the Pope after
        
        taking an oath of allegiance to the apostolic see. He left Rome armed with
        
        letters to Charles Martel and other prominent persons and began to continue the
        
        evangelization of Hesse and Thuringia. He called from
        
        England a band of missionaries, both monks and nuns. Pagan practices were still
        
        rife among the native semi-Christians. Among them was the veneration of sacred
        
        trees, a survival of which remains in the so-called 'Christmas tree', which was
        
        introduced into England from Germany in the nineteenth century. Boniface
        
        endeavored to strike at the root of the evil by felling an oak dedicated to
        
        Thor, near Fritzlar, and from the timber he erected a
        
        chapel dedicated to St. Peter. His courage was rewarded by a large number of
        
        conversions. In 732 Gregory III made him an archbishop
         After the death of Charles Martel, in 741, and the accession of his son
        
        Pepin III, the activity of Boniface became even wider than before. Helped by Carloman and Pepin, and by Pope Zacharias, he set to work
        
        to reform the whole Frankish Church. In 742 began a series of Church Councils;
        
        the rules of the Church were enforced, heathen practices condemned, and
        
        dioceses were grouped under metropolitan sees. Some difficulties came from
        
        within the Church; Boniface had to deal with the heresy of an Irish priest
        
        named Clement and the 'prophecies' of a Frankish bishop named Aldebert. Their opposition failed, and in 744 he prepared to
        
        occupy the important see of Cologne. But the deposition of Gewilib,
        
        Archbishop of Mainz, made it seem desirable that Boniface should be the new
        
        Archbishop of Mainz, a place of pre-eminent influence. He resigned the see in
        
        order to devote his closing years to Frisia, the
        
        country of his first evangelistic efforts. He went there with a large body of
        
        fellow workers and many thousands of Frisians were added to the Church. But he
        
        had not long to wait for a martyr's crown. On the Eve of Whitsunday, June the
        
        5th, 754, at a place near Dokkum, where he arranged
        
        to administer confirmation, he was met by a band of heathens, who slew him and
        
        his fifty-two companions. His remains were afterwards removed to the monastery
        
        church of Fulda, which he had founded.
         Boniface was certainly both one of the noblest and one of the most
        
        successful of missionaries ever born on English soil. The Christianity of
        
        Germany, fragmentary and without spiritual control, was in danger of sinking into the worship of Thor and Odin. Boniface saw the
        
        peril, and by making the Churches of Bavaria, Hesse,
        
        and Thuringia coherent systems united to each other and subject to Rome, he
        
        consolidated both the religion and the culture of a vital part of central
        
        Europe, and prepared for. their expansion to the north and to the east.
         Pepin III (d. 768) was consecrated and crowned as King of the Franks,
        
        some say by St. Boniface himself. To be solemnly crowned was the custom of the
        
        Byzantine Emperors, who in this had copied a practice of the Jews as old as the
        
        time of Samuel and Saul. The ceremony impressed the Franks and Pepin had it
        
        repeated. Pope Stephen II, threatened by the Lombard king Aistulf,
        
        fled to Gaul. He was received with great honor, and in July 754 himself crowned
        
        Pepin in the abbey of Saint-Denis. Thus began in France the theory that a king
        
        rules by 'right divine', a theory which held sway in France for more than a
        
        thousand years, until the downfall of Louis XVI. Stephen bestowed upon Pepin
        
        the title of 'patrician of the Romans', a title which had been given to foreign
        
        princes in former days by Roman Emperors.
         If Charles Martel had proved himself the defender of Christendom, Pepin
        
        proved himself the protector of the Pope. He twice invaded Italy, defeated Aistulf, and sent an envoy into the exarchate of Ravenna to
        
        demand the keys of the cities of the exarchate. He then bestowed the exarchate
        
        with twenty-two towns upon 'St. Peter and his successors'. This was a doubly
        
        significant event. It was the foundation of the Papal States; over which the
        
        Popes exercised temporal power until 187o. It was also the nearly complete
        
        severance of Italy from the Eastern Empire.
         
 CHARLEMAGNE
         Charlemagne (c. 742-814), great in history and even
          
          greater in legend, succeeded Pepin III.
                     Desiderius, King of
          
          the Lombards, the successor of Aistulf, wrested from
          
          the Pope the cities of which Aistulf had been
          
          deprived. Thereupon Pope Hadrian I appealed to Charlemagne, who was then
          
          fighting against the Saxons. He crossed the Alps, began the siege of Pavia, and
          
          went to Rome, where he kept the Easter of 774 and renewed the donation made to
          
          the Pope by his father, Pepin III. He then witnessed the capitulation of Pavia
          
          and was crowned King of the Lombards. The peninsula, however, was not at peace.
          
          In 799 Pope Leo III was attacked and wounded by the family of his predecessor,
          
          Hadrian. He fled for refuge to Charlemagne, then at Paderborn, and the two
          
          returned to Rome in triumph.
           Leo had previously recognized the temporal supremacy of Charlemagne over
          
          Rome, even sending to him the keys of St. Peter's tomb. And now, on Christmas
          
          Day 800, Charlemagne knelt before the tomb, and was crowned by the Pope and
          
          proclaimed Emperor and Augustus. The great significance of Charlemagne's
          
          coronation is this. The old Eastern Roman Empire still existed at Constantinople.
          
          But the old Latin Empire of the West was dead and had been replaced in a large
          
          measure by the papacy. Charlemagne by becoming the master of northern and
          
          central Italy and receiving an imperial crown at Rome, made his Empire appear as the continuation of the Roman Empire of the West. But
          
          he also transferred to his Empire much of the spiritual prestige and
          
          international cohesion of the Catholic Church of the Latin world. His rule was
          
          theocratic. The Pope was a necessary part of this theocracy. He was the power beside
          
          the king, but he was not behind the king; the king often acted on his own
          
          initiative. And though the Carolingian kingdom was soon severed, the influence
          
          of the close union between Church and State under Charlemagne was not
          
          forgotten. It left a deep mark upon the institutions of the Church and prepared
          
          for the later rivalry between the Empire and the Papacy.
           The conversion of the Saxons was the result of the conquests of
          
          Charlemagne. The Saxons, like the Frisians, had no love for Christianity, for
          
          to them Christianity was in a special sense the Frankish religion as it had
          
          been the Roman religion to the Goths of the sixth century. Two Anglo-Saxon
          
          missionaries, Ewald the Black and Ewald the White, had gone early in the eighth century to
          
          preach to their continental kinsmen and received the martyr's crown.
           Christianity made little or no progress and Charlemagne determined to
          
          subdue a people whose independence was a menace to his empire. His first
          
          expedition (772) resulted in the capture of the stronghold Eresburg and the destruction of Irminsul, a pillar held sacred
          
          by the Saxons. As soon as he left the country the Saxons rose again, and in
          
          spite of treaties, killed every Frankish priest and warrior whom they could
          
          find (782). Charles then punished their treachery by beheading 4,500 Saxons at Verden. After a battle at Detmold, and another on the Hase, the power of the Saxons crumbled, and by 804 it was
          
          crushed. In 786 the law forbade, under pain of death, the practice of heathen
          
          rites and the refusal of Christian baptism. The two Saxon chiefs Widukind and Abbio then received
          
          baptism. Bishoprics were founded at Bremen, Minden, and Verden,
          
          and before long Minster, Paderborn, and Halberstadt were added.
           The subjugation of the Saxons by Charlemagne was connected with a
          
          serious interlude in Spain.
           THE CHANSON OF ROLAND The Muslim conquest of Spain in 732 drove back the Christian frontier
          
          far north, so that by 756 it only included the Asturias, Santander, parts of
          
          Burgos, Leon, and Galicia. The invaders, however, were torn by dissensions, and
          
          it was not until the arrival of Abdurrahman at Seville, in the latter year,
          
          that the Muslim power began to be united and secure. In 777 Arabi,
          
          governor of Barcelona, formed a league against Abdurrahman and invited the help
          
          of Charlemagne. Charles, believing that he had sufficiently tamed the Saxons,
          
          crossed the Pyrenees with an army and besieged Saragossa. He was recalled by
          
          the news that Widukind had returned to Saxony and had
          
          reached Cologne, and it was on his way back to France through Roncesvalles that
          
          the rear-guard of his army was annihilated by the Basques. There Roland fell,
          
          the hero immortalized in the 'Chanson de Roland'. It is a sober and noble epic.
          
          The oldest recension of it is the work of an
          
          Anglo-Norman scribe of the twelfth century, and is in the Bodleian Library,
          
          Oxford. Following the lines that we should expect in popular tradition and
          
          poetry, the defeat of Charlemagne's forces is represented as a national
          
          disaster, and the Basque assailants become a vast army of Saracens, Muslims who
          
          are the sworn foes of Franks and Christendom.
           Abdurrahman beat his fellow Muslim and captured Saragossa. But eighteen
          
          years later Charlemagne conquered the Spanish March beyond the Pyrenees and in
          
          801 he extended his sway over Barcelona.
           THE THEOLOGICAL EMPEROR
           Charlemagne was in some degree like Constantine and the other
          
          'theological emperors' of the fourth century. He seriously regarded himself as
          
          the protector of Christianity, one whose warriors would defend the bodies of
          
          the faithful and whose priests would defend their souls. His great mental
          
          activity, his genius for organization, and his grasp of detail were all at the
          
          service of the Church. Under his influence no less than 477 decisions affecting
          
          religion and morals were passed by various ecclesiastical councils, and the
          
          work begun by St. Boniface gained year by year in strength and symmetry.
           The spiritual life of cathedral churches was stimulated by Chrodegang, Bishop of Metz, who formed a group of canons
          
          leading a common life but keeping their private property. Monastic life
          
          received a new impulse from Witiza, a Languedocian who became known as Benedict of Aniane. And around each bishop the cathedral chapter became
          
          a seminary for teaching priests the elements of their clerical duties. Charlemagne
          
          was more than modern in his passion for holding examinations. His clergy were
          
          not only examined before they were ordained, but were examined after as to the
          
          baptisms they administered, the liturgy, their own belief, and their own
          
          conduct. Charlemagne, though he could speak Latin and understood Greek, could
          
          hardly write at all. But he demanded essays on baptism from his clergy, and by
          
          insisting on the regular administration of holy unction, he endeavored to
          
          provide his subjects with the best means for facing death as well as for
          
          receiving a new birth in Christ.
           Side by side with the cathedral and monastic churches were schools. Some
          
          of these schools possessed good libraries. Books were copied, and copied in an
          
          improved and legible handwriting. Among these books the Bible held the first
          
          place. Of the scholars whom Charlemagne delighted to honor at least four must
          
          be mentioned here. The first was Paul the Deacon, an Italian, who wrote a
          
          valuable history of the Lombards. The second was Theodulf,
          
          a Spaniard, who was the best Latin poet of the time. The third was Einhard, a German, who wrote an excellent 'Life' of his
          
          patron. But the foremost was the wise and attractive Englishman, Alcuin (d.
          
          804), who had been trained among the good scholarly traditions of York. In his
          
          library at York he had a Bible which was brought to Tours and served as the
          
          basis of a revised version of the Scriptures. Roman liturgical books also
          
          appeared, and the most important of them was the Gregorian Sacramentary.
          
          By the imperial command this Roman book, with some modifications, replaced the
          
          old Gallican books of France. As time went on, the
          
          old Roman books yielded more and more to Frankish
          
          books which were not purely Roman, and in Rome itself the liturgy became
          
          infected with Frankish influence. But, broadly speaking, liturgical anarchy,
          
          was checked. The subjects of Charlemagne worshipped after the manner of the
          
          king's chapel, the chapel at Aix, which was copied from the church of San
          
          Vitale at Ravenna and resounded with the Roman chant.
           Charlemagne did not confine his care to the externals of worship or the
          
          instruction given in schools and pulpits. He concerned himself with three
          
          subjects of great doctrinal importance. Western Christendom had not been
          
          represented at the Second Council of Nicaea, held in 787, the Council which
          
          defended the use and veneration of sacred pictures or images. Reports of this
          
          Council raised grave misgivings in the West, where it was supposed that the
          
          Council had sanctioned the rendering of 'adoration' or divine worship to
          
          representations of our Lord and His saints. A Council held in 794 at Frankfurt,
          
          under the patronage of Charlemagne, denounced the Second Council of Nicaea as
          
          'most inept' and repudiated the worship of images. The 'Caroline Books' were
          
          composed recording this doctrine and sent to Pope Hadrian, who deferred
          
          publishing the acts of the Council of Nicaea. The use of pictures and images as
          
          means of instruction was permitted among the Franks, but it was long before
          
          their Church tolerated the practice of surrounding them with the tapers and the
          
          incense so dear to the heart of Oriental Christendom.
           But at Frankfurt Charlemagne did more than tilt against images with his
          
          potent lance. He defended the Catholic doctrine of Christ’s Person. Elipandus, Archbishop of Toledo, revived in a new form the
          
          old heresy of Adoptionism, teaching that our Lord in
          
          his human nature was only the adopted Son of God. As the
            
            older form of Adoptionism was acceptable to some
            
            Christians exposed to the opposition of Jews who denied the Deity of Christ, so
            
            this later form gained followers in a country where Muslims denied that
            
            cardinal verity. The heresy was also introduced into Languedoc by a
          
          bishop named Felix. The Council of Frankfurt discussed and condemned this
          
          error, and Charlemagne sent bishops who persuaded Felix to abandon Adoptionism.
           The Church of Spain appears to have influenced Charlemagne at another
          
          point. The truth that the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Father had been
          
          asserted by St. John and by the Ecumenical Councils, and was enshrined in the
          
          Creed. The further statement that the Holy Spirit proceeds also from the Son
          
          was widely accepted in the West and seems implied in the more mature doctrine
          
          of some celebrated Eastern fathers. At Toledo in 589 a great Council pronounced
          
          an anathema on any one who denied that the Holy Spirit proceeds 'from the Son',
          
          and the practice of inserting these words in the creed sung at the liturgy
          
          began gradually to prevail. As Charlemagne's rule extended into Spain as far as
          
          Barcelona, some of his subjects must have been familiar with the new practice.
          
          It was in agreement with the teaching of St. Augustine, and Charlemagne's
          
          favorite reading was the noble treatise of that saint called the 'City of God'.
          
          It is therefore not surprising that the Filioque was adopted in the royal chapel and spread
          
          throughout the Frankish Church. It very soon became a stumbling-block to
          
          Oriental Christians, who felt that, whether it was true or false, it was an
          
          interpolation inserted without adequate authority into one of the most
          
          hallowed monuments of the Christian faith.
           To the Christian student it comes as a shock to learn that this fervent
          
          defender of Christianity and patron of culture, who cared alike for the learned
          
          and the poor, was in his sexual morality very near the
          
          level of an ancient Jewish monarch. At the instance of Frederick Barbarossa the
          
          anti-pope Pascal III canonized Charlemagne.
           This canonization the Church has not ratified, and Charlemagne is
          
          numbered among her benefactors but not among her saints.
           
 CHAPTER VI
            CATHOLICISM AND NATIONALISM IN THE NINTH CENTURY
             |