|
THE BLACK DEATH
IN THE FOURTEENTH CENTURY
By I. F.
C. HECKER
Translated By B.G.
BABINGTON
Chapter
I.—General Observations
Chapter II.—The
Disease
Chapter III.—Causes—
Spread
Chapter
IV.—Mortality
Chapter V.—Moral
Effects
Chapter
VI.—Physicians
PREFACE.
We here find an
important page of the history of the world laid open to our view. It treats of
a convulsion of the human race, unequalled in violence and extent. It speaks of
incredible disasters, of despair and unbridled demoniacal passions. It shows us
the abyss of general licentiousness, in consequence of an universal pestilence,
which extended from China to Iceland and Greenland.
The inducement to
unveil this image of an age, long since gone by, is evident. A new pestilence
has attained almost an equal extent, and though less formidable, has partly
produced, partly indicated, similar phenomena. Its causes and its diffusion
over Asia and Europe, call on us to take a comprehensive view of it, because it
leads to an insight into the organism of the world, in which the sum of organic
life is subject to the great powers of Nature. Now, human knowledge is not yet
sufficiently advanced, to discover the connection between the processes which
occur above, and those which occur below, the surface of the earth, or even
fully to explore the laws of nature, an acquaintance with which would be
required, far less to apply them to great phenomena, in which one spring sets a
thousand others in motion.
On this side,
therefore, such a point of view is not to be found, if we would not lose
ourselves in the wilderness of conjectures, of which the world is already too
full: but it may be found in the ample and productive field of historical
research.
History, that
mirror of human life in all its bearings, offers, even for general pestilences,
an inexhaustible, though scarcely explored, mine of facts; here too it asserts
its dignity, as the philosophy of reality delighting in truth.
It is conformable
to its spirit to conceive over the history of the world, is yet in its infancy.
For the honor of that science which should everywhere guide the actions of
mankind, we are induced to express a wish, that it may find room to flourish
amidst the rank vegetation with which the field of German medical science is
unhappily encumbered.
CHAPTER I.
General
Observations
That Omnipotence
which has called the world with all its living creatures into one animated
being, especially reveals himself in the desolation of great pestilences. The
powers of creation come into violent collision; the sultry dryness of the
atmosphere; the subterraneous thunders; the mist of overflowing waters, are the
harbingers of destruction. Nature is not satisfied with the ordinary
alternations of life and death, and the Destroying Angel waves over man and
beast his flaming sword.
These revolutions
are performed in vast cycles, which the spirit of man, limited as it is, to a
narrow circle of perception, is unable to explore. They are, however, greater
terrestrial events than any of those which proceed from the discord, the
distress or the passions of nations. By annihilations they awaken new life; and
when the tumult above and below the earth is past, nature is renovated, and the
mind awakens from torpor and depression to the consciousness of an intellectual
existence.
Were it in any
degree within the power of human research to draw up, in a vivid and connected
form, an historical sketch of such mighty events, after the manner of the
historians of wars and battles, and the migrations of nations, we might then
arrive at clear views with respect to the mental development of the human race,
and the ways of Providence would be more plainly discernible. It would then be
demonstrable, that the mind of nations is deeply affected by the destructive
conflict of the powers of nature, and that great disasters lead to striking
changes in general civilization. For all that exists in man, whether good or
evil, is rendered conspicuous by the presence of great danger. His inmost
feelings are roused — the thought of self-preservation masters his spirit—self denial is put to severe proof, and wherever darkness
and barbarism prevail, there the affrighted mortal flies to the idols of his
superstition, and all laws, human and divine, are criminally violated.
In conformity with
a general law of nature, such a state of excitement, brings about a change,
beneficial or detrimental, according to circumstances, so that nations either
attain a higher degree of moral worth, or sink deeper in ignorance and vice.
All this, however, takes place upon a much grander scale than through the ordinary
vicissitudes of war and peace, or the rise and fall of empires, because the
powers of nature themselves produce plagues, and subjugate the human will,
which, in the contentions of nations, alone predominates.
CHAPTER I.
General
Observations
That Omnipotence
which has called the world with all its living creatures into one animated
being, especially reveals himself in the desolation of great pestilences. The
powers of creation come into violent collision; the sultry dryness of the
atmosphere; the subterraneous thunders; the mist of overflowing waters, are the
harbingers of destruction. Nature is not satisfied with the ordinary
alternations of life and death, and the Destroying Angel waves over man and
beast his flaming sword.
These revolutions are
performed in vast cycles, which the spirit of man, limited as it is, to a
narrow circle of perception, is unable to explore. They are, however, greater
terrestrial events than any of those which proceed from the discord, the
distress or the passions of nations. By annihilations they awaken new life; and
when the tumult above and below the earth is past, nature is renovated, and the
mind awakens from torpor and depression to the consciousness of an intellectual
existence.
Were it in any
degree within the power of human research to draw up, in a vivid and connected
form, an historical sketch of such mighty events, after the manner of the
historians of wars and battles, and the migrations of nations, we might then
arrive at clear views with respect to the mental development of the human race,
and the ways of Providence would be more plainly discernible. It would then be
demonstrable, that the mind of nations is deeply affected by the destructive
conflict of the powers of nature, and that great disasters lead to striking
changes in general civilization. For all that exists in man, whether good or
evil, is rendered conspicuous by the presence of great danger. His inmost
feelings are roused — the thought of self-preservation masters his spirit—self denial is put to severe proof, and wherever darkness
and barbarism prevail, there the affrighted mortal flies to the idols of his
superstition, and all laws, human and divine, are criminally violated.
In conformity with
a general law of nature, such a state of excitement, brings about a change,
beneficial or detrimental, according to circumstances, so that nations either
attain a higher degree of moral worth, or sink deeper in ignorance and vice.
All this, however, takes place upon a much grander scale than through the ordinary
vicissitudes of war and peace, or the rise and fall of empires, because the
powers of nature themselves produce plagues, and subjugate the human will,
which, in the contentions of nations, alone predominates.
CHAPTER
III.
Causes.—Spread
An enquiry into the causes of the Black Death, will
not be without important results in the study of the plagues which have visited
the world, although it cannot advance beyond generalization without entering
upon a field hitherto uncultivated, and, to this hour, entirely unknown. Mighty
revolutions in the organism of the earth, of which we have credible
information, had preceded it. From China to the Atlantic, the foundations of
the earth were shaken,—throughout Asia and Europe the atmosphere was in
commotion, and endangered, by its baneful influence, both vegetable and animal
life.
The series of these great events began in the year
1333, fifteen years before the plague broke out in Europe: they first appeared
in China. Here a parching drought, accompanied by famine, commenced in the
tract of country watered by the rivers Kiang and Hoai.
This was followed by such violent torrents of rain, in and about Kingsai, at that time the capital of the Empire, that,
according to tradition, more than 400,000 people perished in the floods.
Finally, the mountain Tsincheou fell in, and vast
clefts were formed in the earth. In the succeeding year (1334), passing over
fabulous traditions, the neighborhood of Canton was visited by inundations;
whilst in Tche, after an unexampled drought, a plague arose, which is said to
have carried off about 5,000,000 of people. A few months afterwards an
earthquake followed, at and near Kingsai; and
subsequent to the falling in of the mountains of Ki-ming-chan, a lake was formed of more than a hundred leagues in
circumference, where, again, thousands found their grave. In Hou-kouang and Ho-nan, a drought prevailed for five months; and
innumerable swarms of locusts destroyed the vegetation; while famine and
pestilence, as usual, followed in their train. Connected accounts of the
condition of Europe before this great catastrophe, are not to be expected from
the writers of the fourteenth century. It is remarkable, however, that
simultaneously with a drought and renewed floods in China, in 1336, many
uncommon atmospheric phenomena, and in the winter, frequent thunder storms,
were observed in the north of France; and so early as the eventful year of
1333, an eruption of Etna took place. According to the Chinese annals, about
4,000,000 of people perished by famine in the neighborhood of Kiang in 1337;
and deluges, swarms of locusts, and an earthquake which lasted six days, caused
incredible devastation. In the same year, the first swarms of locusts appeared
in Franconia, which were succeeded in the following year by myriads of these
insects. In 1338, Kingsai was visited by an
earthquake of ten days duration; at the same time France suffered from a
failure in the harvest; and thenceforth, till the year 1342, there was in
China, a constant succession of inundations, earthquakes, and famines. In the
same year great floods occurred in the vicinity of the Rhine and in France,
which could not be attributed to rain alone; for, everywhere, even on the tops
of mountains, springs were seen to burst forth, and dry tracts were laid under
water in an inexplicable manner. In the following year, the mountain Hong-tchang, in China, fell in, and caused a destructive deluge;
and in Pien-tcheou and Leang-tcheou, after
three months' rain, there followed unheard of inundations, which destroyed
several cities. In Egypt and Syria, violent earthquakes took place; and in
China they became, from this time, more and more frequent; for they recurred,
in 1344, in Ventcheou, where the sea overflowed in
consequence; in 1345, in Kitcheou, and in both the
following years in Canton, with subterraneous thunder. Meanwhile, floods and
famine devastated various districts, until 1347, when the fury of the elements
subsided in China.
The signs of terrestrial commotions commenced in
Europe in the year 1348, after the intervening districts of country in Asia had
probably been visited in the same manner.
On the island of Cyprus, the plague from the East had
already broken out; when an earthquake shook the foundations of the island, and
was accompanied by so frightful a hurricane, that the inhabitants who had slain
their Mahometan slaves, in order that they might not themselves be subjugated
by them, fled in dismay, in all directions. The sea overflowed—the ships were
dashed to pieces on the rocks, and few outlived the terrific event, whereby
this fertile and blooming island was converted into a desert. Before the
earthquake, a pestiferous wind spread so poisonous an odor, that many, being overpowered
by it, fell down suddenly and expired in dreadful agonies.
This phenomenon is one of the rarest that has ever
been observed, for nothing is more constant than the composition of the air;
and in no respect has nature been more careful in the preservation of organic
life. Never have naturalists discovered in the atmosphere, foreign elements,
which, evident to the senses, and borne by the winds, spread from land to land,
carrying disease over whole portions of the earth, as is recounted to have taken
place in the year 1348. It is, therefore, the more to be regretted, that in
this extraordinary period, which, owing to the low condition of science, was
very deficient in accurate observers, so little that can be depended on
respecting those uncommon occurrences in the air, should have been recorded.
Yet, German accounts say expressly, that a thick, stinking mist advanced from
the East, and spread itself over Italy; and there could be no deception in
so palpable a phenomenon. The credibility of unadorned traditions, however
little they may satisfy to physical research, can scarcely be called in
question when we consider the connection of events; for just at this time
earthquakes were more general than they had been within the range of history.
In thousands of places chasms were formed, from whence arose noxious vapors;
and as at that time natural occurrences were transformed into miracles, it was
reported, that a fiery meteor, which descended on the earth far in the East,
had destroyed everything within a circumference of more than a
hundred leagues, infecting the air far and wide. The
consequences of innumerable floods contributed to the same effect; vast river
districts had been converted into swamps; foul vapors arose everywhere,
increased by the odor of putrefied locusts, which had never perhaps darkened
the sun in thicker swarms, and of countless corpses, which even in the
well-regulated countries of Europe, they knew not how to remove quickly enough
out of the sight of the living. It is probable, therefore, that the atmosphere
contained foreign, and sensibly perceptible, admixtures to a great extent,
which, at least in the lower regions, could not be decomposed, or rendered
ineffective by separation.
Now, if we go back to the symptoms of the disease, the
ardent inflammation of the lungs points out, that the organs of respiration
yielded to the attack of an atmospheric poison—a poison, which (if we admit the
independent origin of the Black Plague at any one place on the globe, which,
under such extraordinary circumstances, it would be difficult to doubt),
attacked the course of the circulation in as hostile a manner as that which
produces inflammation of the spleen and other animal contagions that cause
swelling and inflammation of the lymphatic glands.
Pursuing the course of these grand revolutions
further, we find notice of an unexampled earthquake, which, on the 25th of
January, 1348, shook Greece, Italy and the neighboring countries. Naples, Rome,
Pisa, Bologna, Padua, Venice and many other cities suffered considerably: whole
villages were swallowed up. Castles, houses and churches, were overthrown, and
hundreds of people were buried beneath their ruins. In Carinthia, thirty
villages, together with all the churches, were demolished; more than a thousand
corpses were drawn out of the rubbish; the city of Villach was so completely
destroyed, that very few of its inhabitants were saved; and when the earth
ceased to tremble, it was found that mountains had been moved from their
positions, and that many hamlets were left in ruins. It is recorded, that
during this earthquake, the wine in the casks became turbid, a statement which
may be considered as furnishing a proof, that changes causing a decomposition
of the atmosphere had taken place; but if we had no other information from
which the excitement of conflicting powers of nature during
these commotions, might be inferred, yet Scientific observations in modern
times have shown, that the relation of the atmosphere to the earth is changed
by volcanic influences. Why then, may we not, from this fact, draw
retrospective inferences respecting those extraordinary phenomena?
Independently of this, however, we know that during
this earthquake, the duration of which is stated by some to have been a week,
and by others, a fortnight, people experienced an unusual stupor and
headache, and that many fainted away.
These destructive earthquakes extended as far as the
neighborhood of Basle, and recurred until the year 1360, throughout Germany,
France, Silesia, Poland, England and Denmark, and much further north.
Great and extraordinary meteors appeared in many
places, and were regarded with superstitious horror. A pillar of fire, which on
the 20th of December, 1348, remained for an hour at sun rise over the pope's
palace in Avignon; a fireball, which in August of the same year was seen at
sunset over Paris, and was distinguished from similar phenomena, by its longer
duration, (not to mention other instances mixed up with wonderful
prophecies and omens), are recorded in the chronicles of that age.
The order of the seasons seemed to be inverted,—rains,
floods and failures in crops were so general, that few places were exempt from
them; and though an historian of this century assures us, that there was an
abundance in the granaries and storehouses, all his contemporaries, with one
voice, contradict him. The consequences of failure in the crops were soon felt,
especially in Italy and the surrounding countries, where, in this year, a rain
which continued for four months, had destroyed the seed. In the larger cities,
they were compelled, in the spring of 1347, to have recourse to a distribution
of bread among the poor, particularly at Florence, where they erected large
bake-houses, from which, in April, ninety-four thousand loaves of bread, each
of twelve ounces in weight, were daily dispensed. It is plain, however, that
humanity could only partially mitigate the general distress, not altogether
obviate it.
Diseases, the invariable consequence of famine, broke
out in the country, as well as in cities; children died of hunger in their
mothers' arms,—want, misery and despair, were general throughout Christendom.
Such are the events which took place before the
eruption of the Black Plague in Europe. Contemporaries have explained them
after their own manner, and have thus, like their posterity, under similar
circumstances, given a proof, that mortals possess neither senses nor
intellectual powers sufficiently acute to comprehend the phenomena produced by
the earths organism, much less scientifically to understand their effects.
Superstition, selfishness in a thousand forms, the presumption of the
schools, laid hold of unconnected facts. They vainly thought to comprehend
the whole in the individual, and perceived not the universal spirit which, in
intimate union with the mighty powers of nature, animates the movements of all
existence, and permits not any phenomenon to originate from isolated causes. To
attempt, five centuries after that age of desolation, to point out the causes
of a cosmical commotion, which has never recurred to an equal extent,—to
indicate scientifically the influences which called forth so terrific a poison
in the bodies of men and animals, exceeds the limits of human understanding. If
we are even now unable, with all the varied resources of an extended knowledge
of nature, to define that condition of the atmosphere by which pestilences are
generated, still less can we pretend to reason retrospectively from the
nineteenth to the fourteenth century; but if we take a general view of the
occurrences, that century will give us copious information, and, as applicable
to all succeeding times, of high importance.
In the progress of connected natural phenomena, from
East to West, that great law of nature is plainly revealed which has so often
and evidently manifested itself in the earth's organism, as well as in the
state of nations dependent upon it. In the inmost depths of the globe, that
impulse was given in the year 1333, which in uninterrupted succession for
six-and-twenty years shook the surface of the earth, even to the western shores
of Europe. From the very beginning the air partook of the terrestrial
concussion, atmospherical waters overflowed the land,
or its plants and animals perished under the scorching heat. The insect tribe
was wonderfully called into life, as if animated beings were destined to
complete the destruction which astral and telluric powers had begun. Thus did
this dreadful work of nature advance from year to year; it was a progressive
infection of the Zones which exerted a powerful influence both above and
beneath the surface of the earth; and after having been perceptible in slighter
indications, at the commencement of the terrestrial commotions in China,
convulsed the whole earth.
The nature of the first plague in China is unknown. We
have no certain intelligence of the disease, until it entered the western
countries of Asia. Here it showed itself as the oriental plague with
inflammation of the lungs; in which form it probably also may have begun in
China, that is to say, as a malady which spreads, more than any other, by
contagion—a contagion, that, in ordinary pestilences, requires immediate
contact, and only under unfavorable circumstances of rare occurrence is
communicated by the mere approach to the sick. The share which this cause had
in the spreading of the plague over the whole earth, was certainly very
great: and the opinion that the Black Death might have been excluded
from Western Europe, by good regulations, similar to those which are now in
use, would have all the support of modern experience; provided it could be
proved that this plague had been actually imported from the East; or that the
oriental plague in general, as often as it appears in Europe, always has its
origin in Asia or Egypt. Such a proof, however, cannot be produced so as to
enforce conviction; for it would involve the impossible assumption, that either
there is no essential difference in the degree of civilization of the European
nations, in the most ancient and in modern times, or that detrimental
circumstances, which have yielded only to the civilization of human society and
the regular cultivation of countries, could not formerly have maintained the
bubo-plague.
The plague was, however, known in Europe before
nations were united by the bonds of commerce and social intercourse;
hence there is ground for supposing that it sprung up spontaneously, in
consequence of the rude manner of living and the uncultivated state of the
earth; influences which peculiarly favor the origin of severe diseases. Now, we
need not go back to the earlier centuries, for the 14th itself, before it was
half expired, was visited by five or six pestilences. (1301, in the South of
France; 1311, in Italy; 1316, in Italy, Burgundy and Northern Europe; 1335, the
locust years, in the middle of Europe; 1340, in upper Italy; 1342, in France;
and 1347, in Marseilles and most of the larger islands of the Mediterranean).
If, therefore, we consider the peculiar property of
the plague, that, in countries which it has once visited, it remains for a long
time in a milder form, and that the epidemic influences of 1342, when it had
appeared for the last time, were particularly favorable to its unperceived
continuance, till 1348, we come to the notion, that in this eventful year also,
the germs of plague existed in Southern Europe, which might be vivified by atmospherical deteriorations; and that thus, at least in
part, the Black Plague may have originated in Europe itself. The corruption of
the atmosphere came from the East; but the disease itself came not upon the
wings of the wind, but was only excited and increased by the atmosphere where
it had previously existed.
This source of the Black Plague was not, however, the
only one; for, far more powerful than the excitement of the latent elements of
the plague by atmospheric influences, was the effect of the contagion
communicated from one people to another, on the great roads, and in the harbors
of the Mediterranean. From China, the route of the caravans lay to the north of
the Caspian Sea, through Central Asia, to Tauris. Here ships were ready to take
the produce of the East to Constantinople, the capital of commerce, and the medium
of connection between Asia, Europe and Africa. Other caravans went from India
to Asia Minor, and touched at the cities south of the Caspian Sea, and lastly,
from Bagdad, through Arabia to Egypt; also the maritime communication on the
Red Sea, from India to Arabia and Egypt, was not inconsiderable. In all these
directions contagion made its way; and doubtless, Constantinople and the
harbors of Asia Minor, are to be regarded as the foci of infection; whence it
radiated to the most distant seaports and islands.
To Constantinople, the plague had been brought from
the northern coast of the Black Sea, after it had depopulated the countries
between those routes of commerce; and appeared as early as 1347, in Cyprus,
Sicily, Marseilles and some of the seaports of Italy. The remaining islands of
the Mediterranean, particularly Sardinia, Corsica and Majorca, were visited in
succession. Foci of contagion existed also in full activity along the whole
southern coast of Europe; when, in January 1348, the plague appeared in
Avignon, and in other cities in the south of France and north of Italy, as well
as in Spain. The precise days of its eruption in the individual towns, are no
longer to be ascertained; but it was not simultaneous: for in Florence, the
disease appeared in the beginning of April; in Cesena, the 1st of June; and
place after place was attacked throughout the whole year; so that the plague,
after it had passed through the whole of France and Germany, where, however, it
did not make its ravages until the following year, did not break out till
August, in England; where it advanced so gradually, that a period of three
months elapsed before it reached London. The Northern Kingdoms were attacked by
it in 1349. Sweden, indeed, not until November of that year: almost two years
after its eruption in Avignon. Poland received the plague in 1349, probably
from Germany, if not from the northern countries; but in Russia, it did not
make its appearance until 1351, more than three years after it had broken out
in Constantinople. Instead of advancing in a north-westerly direction from
Tauris and from the Caspian Sea, it had thus made the great circuit of the
Black Sea, by way of Constantinople, Southern and Central Europe, England, the
Northern Kingdoms and Poland, before it reached the Russian territories; a
phenomenon which has not again occurred with respect to more recent pestilences
originating in Asia.
Whether any difference existed between the indigenous
plague, excited by the influence of the atmosphere, and that which was imported
by contagion, can no longer be ascertained from the facts; for the
contemporaries, who in general were not competent to make accurate researches
of this kind, have left no data on the subject. A milder and a more malignant
form certainly existed, and the former was not always derived from the latter,
as is to be supposed from this circumstance—that the spitting of blood, the
infallible diagnostic of the latter, on the first breaking out of the plague,
is not similarly mentioned in all the reports; and it is therefore probable,
that the milder form belonged to the native plague,—the more malignant, to that
introduced by contagion. Contagion was, however, in itself, only one of many
causes which gave rise to the Black Plague.
This disease was a consequence of violent commotions
in the earth's organism—if any disease of cosmical origin can be so considered.
One spring set a thousand others in motion for the annihilation of living
beings, transient or permanent, of mediate or immediate effect. The most powerful
of all was contagion; for in the most distant countries which had scarcely yet
heard the echo of the first concussion, the people fell a sacrifice to organic
poison— the untimely offspring of vital energies thrown into violent commotion.
CHAPTER IV.
Mortality.
We have no certain measure by which to estimate the
ravages of the Black Plague, if numerical statements were wanted, as
in modern times. Let us go back for a moment to the 14th
century. The people were yet but little civilized. The church had indeed
subdued them; but they all suffered from the ill-consequences of
their original rudeness. The dominion of the law was not yet
confirmed. Sovereigns had everywhere to combat powerful enemies to
internal tranquility and security. The cities were fortresses for their own defence.Marauders encamped on the roads. The husbandman was
a feodal slave, without possessions of his own.
Rudeness was general.—Humanity, as yet unknown to the
people. —Witches and heretics were burned alive.—Gentle rulers were condemned
as weak;—wild passions, severity and cruelty, everywhere predominated.—Human
life was little regarded.—Governments concerned not themselves about the
numbers of their subjects, for whose welfare it was incumbent on them to
provide. Thus, the first requisite for estimating the loss of human life,
namely, a knowledge of the amount of the population, is altogether wanting;
and, moreover, the traditional statements of the amount of this loss, are so
vague, that from this source likewise, there is only room for probable
conjecture.
Kairo lost daily, when the plague was raging with its
greatest violence, from 10 to 15,000; being as many as, in modern times, great
plagues have carried off during their whole course. In China, more than
thirteen millions are said to have died; and this is in correspondence with the
certainly exaggerated accounts from the rest of Asia. India was depopulated.
Tartary, the Tartar Kingdom of Kaptschak, Mesapotamia, Syria, Armenia, were covered with dead
bodies—the Kurds fled in vain to the mountains. In Caramania and Caesarea, none were left alive. On the roads,—in the camps,—in the
caravansaries,— unburied bodies alone were seen; and a few cities only (Arabian
historians name, Maara el nooman, Schisur and Harem)
remained, in an unaccountable manner, free. In Aleppo, 500 died daily; 22,000
people, and most of the animals, were carried off in Gaza, within six weeks.
Cyprus lost almost all its inhabitants; and ships without crews were often seen
in the Mediterranean; as afterwards in the North Sea, driving about, and
spreading the plague wherever they went on shore. It was reported to Pope
Clement, at Avignon, that throughout the East, probably with the exception of
China, 23,840,000 people had fallen victims to the plague. Considering the
occurrences of the 14th and 15th centuries, we might, on first view, suspect
the accuracy of this statement. How (it might be asked) could such great wars
have been carried on—such powerful efforts have been made; how could the Greek
empire, only a hundred years later, have been overthrown, if the people really
had been so utterly destroyed?
This account is nevertheless rendered credible by the
ascertained fact, that the palaces of princes are less accessible to contagious
diseases, than the dwellings of the multitude; and that in places of
importance, the influx from those districts which have suffered least, soon
repairs even the heaviest losses. We must remember also, that we do not gather
much from mere numbers without an intimate knowledge of the state of Society.
We will, therefore, confine ourselves to exhibiting some of the more credible
accounts relative to European cities.
In Florence there died of the Black
Plague - - 60,000.
In Venice - - 100,000.
In Marseilles, in one month 16,000.
In Siena - - - 70,000.
In Paris - - - 50,000.
In St. Denys - - 14,000.
In Avignon - - 60,000.
In Strasburg - - 16,000.
In Lübeck - - 9,000.
In Basle - - - 14,000.
In Erfurt, at least - 16,000.
In Weimar - - 5,000.
In Limburg - - 2,500.
In London, at least - 100,000.
In Norwich - - 51,100.
To which may be added—
Franciscan Friars in Germany 124,434.
Minorites in Italy - - 30,000.
This short catalogue might, by a laborious
and uncertain calculation, deduced from other sources, be easily further
multiplied, but would still fail to give a true picture of the depopulation
which took place. Lübeck, at that time the Venice of the North, which could no
longer contain the multitudes that flocked to it, was thrown into such
consternation on the eruption of the plague, that the citizens destroyed
themselves as if in frenzy.
Merchants whose earnings and possessions were
unbounded, coldly and willingly renounced their earthly goods. They carried
their treasures to monasteries and churches, and laid them at the foot of the
altar; but gold had no charms for the monks, for it brought them death. They
shut their gates; yet, still it was cast to them over the convent walls. People
would brook no impediment to the last pious work to which they were driven by despair.
When the plague ceased, men thought they were still wandering among the dead,
so appalling was the livid aspect of the survivors, in consequence of the
anxiety they had undergone, and the unavoidable infection of the air. Many
other cities probably presented a similar appearance; and it is ascertained
that a great number of small country towns and villages which have been
estimated, and not too highly, at 200,000, were bereft of all their
inhabitants.
In many places in France not more than two out of
twenty of the inhabitants were left alive, and the capital felt the fury of the
plague, alike in the palace and the cot.
Two queens, one bishop, and great numbers of other
distinguished persons, fell a sacrifice to it, and more than 500 a day died in
the Hôtel-Dieu, under the faithful care of the sisters of charity, whose
disinterested courage, in this age of horror, displayed the most
beautiful traits of human virtue. For although they lost their lives, evidently
from contagion, and their numbers were several times renewed, there was still
no want of fresh candidates, who, strangers to the unchristian fear of death,
piously devoted themselves to their holy calling.
The churchyards were soon unable to contain the dead,
and many houses, left without inhabitants, fell to ruins.
In Avignon, the pope found it necessary to consecrate
the Rhone, that bodies might be thrown into the river without delay, as the
church-yards would no longer hold them; so likewise, in all populous cities,
extraordinary measures were adopted, in order speedily to dispose of the dead.
In Vienna, where for some time 1200 inhabitants died daily, the interment of
corpses in the church-yards and within the churches, was forthwith prohibited;
and the dead were then arranged in layers, by thousands, in six large pits
outside the city, as had already been done in Cairo and Paris. Yet, still many
were secretly buried; for at all times, the people are attached to the
consecrated cemeteries of their dead, and will not renounce the customary mode
of interment.
In many places, it was rumored that plague patients
were buried alive, as may sometimes happen through senseless alarm and indecent
haste; and thus the horror of the distressed people was everywhere increased.
In Erfurt, after the church-yards were filled, 12,000 corpses were thrown into
eleven great pits; and the like might, more or less exactly, be stated with
respect to all the larger cities. Funeral ceremonies, the last consolation of
the survivors, were everywhere impracticable.
In all Germany, according to a probable calculation,
there seem to have died only 1,244,434 inhabitants; this country, however, was
more spared than others: Italy, on the contrary, was most severely visited. It
is said to have lost half its inhabitants; and this account is rendered
credible from the immense losses of individual cities and provinces: for in
Sardinia and Corsica, according to the account of the distinguished Florentine,
John Villani, who was himself carried off by the Black Plague, scarcely a third
part of the population remained alive; and it is related of the Venetians, that
they engaged ships at a high rate to retreat to the islands; so that after the
plague had carried off three fourths of her inhabitants, that proud city was
left forlorn and desolate. In Padua, after the cessation of the plague, two
thirds of the inhabitants were wanting; and in Florence it was prohibited to
publish the numbers of the dead, and to toll the bells at their funerals, in
order that the living might not abandon themselves to despair. We have more
exact accounts of England; most of the great cities suffered incredible losses;
above all, Yarmouth, in which, 7052 died: Bristol, Oxford, Norwich, Leicester,
York and London where, in one burial ground alone, there were interred upwards
of 50,000 corpses, arranged in layers, in large pits. It is said, that in the
whole country, scarcely a tenth part remained alive; but this estimate is
evidently too high. Smaller losses were sufficient to cause those convulsions,
whose consequences were felt for some centuries, in a false impulse given to
civil life, and whose indirect influence, unknown to the English, has, perhaps,
extended even to modern times.
Morals were deteriorated everywhere, and the service
of God was, in a great measure, laid aside; for, in many places, the churches
were deserted, being bereft of their priests. The instruction of the people was
impeded; covetousness became general; and when tranquility was restored, the
great increase of lawyers was astonishing, to whom the endless disputes
regarding inheritances, offered a rich harvest. The want of priests too,
throughout the country, operated very detrimentally upon the people (the lower
classes being most exposed to the ravages of the plague, whilst the houses of
the nobility were, in proportion, much more spared) and it was no compensation
that whole bands of ignorant laymen, who had lost their wives during the
pestilence, crowded into the monastic orders, that they might participate in
the respectability of the priesthood, and in the rich heritages which fell in
to the church from all quarters. The sittings of Parliament, of the King's
Bench, and of most of the other courts, were suspended as long as the malady
raged. The laws of peace availed not during the dominion of death. Pope Clement
took advantage of this state of disorder, to adjust the bloody quarrel between
Edward III and Philip VI; yet he only succeeded during the period that the
plague commanded peace. Philip's death (1350) annulled all treaties; and it is related,
that Edward, with other troops indeed, but with the same leaders and knights,
again took the field. Ireland was much less heavily visited than England. The
disease seems to have scarcely reached the mountainous districts of that
kingdom; and Scotland too would, perhaps, have remained free, had not the Scots
availed themselves of the discomfiture of the English, to make an irruption
into their territory, which terminated in the destruction of their army, by the
plague and by the sword, and the extension of the pestilence, through those who
escaped, over the whole country.
At the commencement, there was in England a
superabundance of all the necessaries of life; but the plague, which seemed
then to be the sole disease, was soon accompanied by a fatal murrain among
cattle. Wandering about without herdsmen, they fell by thousands; and, as has
likewise been observed in Africa, the birds and beasts of prey are said not to
have touched them. Of what nature this murrain may have been, can no more be
determined, than whether it originated from communication with plague patients,
or from other causes; but thus much is certain, that
it did not break out until after the commencement of the Black Death. In
consequence of this murrain, and the impossibility of removing the corn from
the fields, there was every where a great rise in the
price of food, which to many
was inexplicable, because the harvest had been plentiful;
by others it was attributed to the wicked designs of the laborers and dealers;
but it had its foundation in the actual deficiency, arising from circumstances
by which individual classes at all times endeavour to
profit. For a whole year, until it terminated in August, 1349, the Black Plague
prevailed in this beautiful island, and every where poisoned the springs of comfort and prosperity.
In other countries, it generally lasted only half a
year, but returned frequently in individual places; on which account, some,
without sufficient proof, assigned to it a period of seven years.
Spain was uninterruptedly ravaged by the Black Plague
till after the year 1350, to which the frequent internal feuds and the wars
with the Moors not a little contributed. Alphonso XI, whose passion for war
carried him too far, died of it at the siege of Gibraltar, on the 26th of
March, 1350. He was the only king in Europe who fell a sacrifice to it; but
even before this period, innumerable families had been thrown into affliction.
The mortality seems otherwise to have been smaller in Spain than in Italy, and
about as considerable as in France.
The whole period during which the Black Plague raged
with destructive violence in Europe, was, with the exception of Russia, from
the year 1347 to 1350. The plagues, which in the sequel often returned until
the year 1383, we do not consider as belonging to "the Great
Mortality." They were rather common pestilences,
without inflammation of the lungs, such as in former times, and in the
following centuries, were excited by the matter of contagion everywhere existing,
and which, on every favorable occasion, gained ground anew, as is usually the
case with this frightful disease.
The concourse of large bodies of people was especially
dangerous; and thus, the premature celebration of the Jubilee, to which Clement
VI cited the faithful to Rome, (1350), during the great epidemic, caused a new
eruption of the plague, from which it is said, that scarcely one in an hundred of the pilgrims escaped.
Italy was, in consequence, depopulated anew; and those
who returned, spread poison and corruption of morals in all directions. It is,
therefore, the less apparent, how that Pope, who was in
general so wise and considerate, and who knew how to pursue the path of reason
and humanity, under the most difficult circumstances, should have been led to
adopt a measure so injurious; since he, himself, was so convinced of the
salutary effect of seclusion, that during the plague in Avignon, he kept up
constant fires, and suffered no one to approach him; and, in other respects,
gave such orders as averted, or alleviated, much misery.
The changes which occurred about this period in the
north of Europe, are sufficiently memorable to claim a few moments attention.
In Sweden, two princes died—Haken and Knut, half-brothers of King Magnus; and
in Westgothland alone, 466 priests. The inhabitants
of Iceland and Greenland, found in the coldness of their inhospitable climate,
no protection against the southern enemy who had penetrated to them from
happier countries. The plague caused great havoc among them. Nature made no
allowance for their constant warfare with the elements, and the parsimony with
which she had meted out to them the enjoyments of life. In Denmark and Norway,
however, people were so occupied with their own misery, that the accustomed
voyages to Greenland ceased. Towering icebergs formed at the same time on the
coast of East Greenland, in consequence of the general concussion of the
earth's organism; and no mortal, from that time forward, has ever seen that
shore or its inhabitants. It has been observed above, that in Russia,
the Black Plague did not break out until 1351, after it had already passed
through the south and north of Europe. In this country also, the mortality was
extraordinarily great; and the same scenes of affliction and despair were
exhibited, as had occurred in those nations which had already passed the
ordeal. The same mode of burial—the same horrible certainty of death—the same
torpor and depression of spirits. The wealthy abandoned their treasures, and
gave their villages and estates to the churches and monasteries; this beings
according to the notions of the age, the surest way of securing the favor of
Heaven and the forgiveness of past sins. In Russia too, the voice of nature was
silenced by fear and horror. In the hour of danger, fathers and mothers
deserted their children, and children their parents.
Of all the estimates of the number of lives lost in
Europe, the most probable is, that altogether, a fourth part of the inhabitants
were carried off. Now, if Europe at present contain 210,000,000 inhabitants,
the population, not to take a higher estimate, which might easily be justified,
amounted to at least 105,000,000, in the 16th century.
It may, therefore, be assumed, without exaggeration,
that Europe lost during the Black Death, 26,000,000 of inhabitants.
That her nations could so quickly overcome such a
fearful concussion in their external circumstances, and, in general, without
retrograding more than they actually did, could so develop their energies in
the following century, is a most convincing proof of the indestructibility of
human society as a whole. To assume, however, that it did not suffer any
essential change internally, because in appearance everything remained as
before, is inconsistent with a just view of cause and effect. Many historians
seem to have adopted such an opinion; accustomed, as usual, to judge of the
moral condition of the people solely according to the vicissitudes of earthly
power, the events of battles, and the influence of religion, but to pass over
with indifference, the great phenomena of nature, which modify, not only the
surface of the earth, but also the human mind. Hence, most of them have touched
but superficially on the "great mortality" of the 14th century. We,
for our parts are convinced, that in the history of the world, the Black Death
is one of the most important events which have prepared the way for the present
state of Europe. He who studies the human mind with attention, and forms a
deliberate judgment on the intellectual powers which set people and states in
motion, may, perhaps, find some proofs of this assertion in the following
observations:—at that time the advancement of the hierarchy was, in most
countries, extraordinary; for the church acquired treasures and large
properties in land, even to a greater extent than after the crusades; but
experience has demonstrated, that such a state of things is ruinous to the
people, and causes them to retrograde, as was evinced on this occasion.
After the cessation of the Black Plague, a greater
fertility in women was everywhere remarkable—a grand phenomenon, which, from
its occurrence after every destructive pestilence, proves to conviction, if any
occurrence can do so the prevalence of a higher power in the direction of
general organic life. Marriages were, almost without exception, prolific; and
double and treble births were more frequent than at other times; under which
head, we should remember the strange remark, that after the "great
mortality" the children were said to have got fewer teeth than before; at
which, contemporaries were mightily shocked, and even later writers have felt
surprise.
If we examine the grounds of this repeated assertion
we shall find that they were astonished, to see children cut twenty, or at
most, twenty-two teeth, under the supposition that a greater number bad
formerly fallen to their share. Some writers of authority, as, for example, the
physician Savonarola, at Ferrara, who probably looked for
twenty-eight teeth in children, published their opinions on this subject.
Others copied from them, without seeing for themselves, as often happens in
other matters which are equally evident; and thus the world believed in the
miracle of an imperfection in the human body which had been caused by the Black
Plague.
The people gradually consoled themselves after the
sufferings which they had undergone; the dead were lamented and forgotten; and
in the stirring vicissitudes of existence, the world belonged to the living.
CHAPTER V.
Moral Effects.
The mental shock sustained by all nations during the
prevalence of the Black Plague, is without parallel and beyond description. In
the eyes of the timorous, danger was the certain harbinger of death; many fell
victims to fear, on the first appearance of the distemper, and the most
stouthearted lost their confidence. Thus, after reliance on the future had died
away, the spiritual union which binds man to his family and his fellow
creatures, was gradually dissolved. The pious closed their accounts with the
world,—eternity presented itself to their view,—their only remaining desire,
was for a participation in the consolations of religion, because to them death
was disarmed of its sting. Repentance seized the transgressor, admonishing him
to consecrate his remaining hours to the exercise of Christian virtues. All
minds were directed to the contemplation of futurity; and children, who
manifest the more elevated feelings of the soul without alloy, were frequently
seen, while laboring under the plague, breathing out their spirit with prayer
and songs of thanksgiving.
An awful sense of contrition seized Christians of
every communion; they resolved to& forsake their vices—to make restitution
for past offences, before they were summoned hence—to seek reconciliation with
their Maker, and to avert, by self-chastisement, the punishment due to their
former sins. Human nature would be exalted, could the countless noble actions, which,in times of most imminent danger, were performed in
secret, be recorded for the instruction of future generations. They, however,
have no influence on the course of worldly events. They are known only to
silent eye-witnesses, and soon fall into oblivion. But hypocrisy, illusion and
bigotry, stalk abroad undaunted; they desecrate what is noble—they pervert what
is divine, to the unholy purposes of selfishness; which hurries along every
good feeling& in the false excitement of the age. Thus it was in the years
of this plague. In the 14th century, the monastic system was still in its foil vigour,—the power of the ecclesiastical orders and
brotherhoods, was revered by the people, and the hierarchy was still formidable
to the temporal power. It was, therefore, in the natural constitution of
society that bigoted zeal, which in such times makes a show of public acts of
penance, should avail itself of the semblance of religion. But this took place
in such a manner, that unbridled, self-willed penitence, degenerated into luke-warmness, renounced obedience to the hierarchy, and
prepared a fearful opposition to the church, paralyzed by antiquated forms.
While all countries were filled with lamentations and
woe, there first arose in Hungary, and afterwards in Germany, the Brotherhood
of the Flagellants, called also the Brethren of the Cross, or Cross-bearers,
who took upon themselves the repentance of the people, for the sins they had
committed, and offered prayers and supplications tor the averting of this
plague. This Order consisted chiefly of persons of the lower class, who were
either actuated by sincere contrition, or, who joyfully availed themselves of
this pretext for idleness, and were hurried along with the tide of distracting
frenzy. But, as these brotherhoods gained in repute, and were welcomed by the
people with veneration and enthusiasm, many nobles and ecclesiastics ranged
themselves under their standard; and their bands were not unfrequently
augmented by children, honorable women and nuns; so powerfully were minds of
the most opposite temperaments enslaved by this infatuation. They marched
through the cities, in well-organized processions, with leaders and singers;
their heads covered as far as the eyes; their look fixed on the ground,
accompanied by every token of the deepest contrition and mourning. They were
robed in sombre garments, with red crosses on the
breast, back, and cap; and bare triple scourges, tied n three or four knots, in
which points of iron were fixed. Tapers and magnificent banners of velvet and
cloth of gold, were carried before them; wherever they made their appearance,
they were welcomed by the ringing of the bells; and the people flocked from all
quarters, to listen to their hymns and to witness their penance, with devotion
and tears. In the year 1349, two hundred Flagellants first entered Strasburg,
where they were received with great joy, and hospitably lodged by the citizens.
Above a thousand joined the brotherhood, which now assumed the appearance of a
wandering tribe, and separated into two bodies, for the purpose of journeying
to the north and to the south. For more than half a year new parties arrived
weekly; and, on each arrival, adults and children left their families to
accompany them; till, at length, their sanctity was questioned, and the doors
of houses and churches were closed against them. At Spires, two hundred boys,
of twelve years of age and under, constituted themselves into a Brotherhood of
the Cross, in imitation of the children, who, about a hundred years before, had
united, at the instigation of some fanatic monks, for the purpose of
recovering the Holy Sepulchre. All the
inhabitants of this town, were carried away by the
illusion; they conducted the strangers to their houses with songs of
thanksgiving, to regale them for the night. The women embroidered banners for
them, and all were anxious to augment their pomp; and at every
succeeding pilgrimage, their
influence and reputation increased. It was not merely some
individual parts of the country that fostered them: all Germany, Hungary,
Poland, Bohemia, Silesia and Flanders, did homage to the mania; and they at
length became as formidable to the secular, as they were to the ecclesiastical
power. The influence of this fanaticism, was great and threatening;
resembling the excitement which called all the inhabitants of Europe into the
deserts of Syria and Palestine, about two hundred and fifty years before. The
appearance, in itself, was not novel. As far back as the 11th century, many
believers, in Asia and Southern Europe, afflicted themselves with the
punishment of flagellation. Dominicus Loricatus, a
monk of St. Croce d'Avellano, is mentioned as the
master and model of this species of mortification of the flesh; which,
according to the primitive notions of the Asiatic Anchorites, was deemed
eminently Christian. The author of the solemn processions of the Flagellants,
is said to have been St. Anthony; for even in his time (1231), this kind of
penance was so much in vogue, that it is recorded as an eventful circumstance
in the history of the world. In 1260, the Flagellants appeared in Italy
as Devoti. “When the land was polluted by
vices and crimes, an unexampled spirit of remorse suddenly seized the minds of
the Italians. The fear of Christ fell upon all: noble and ignoble, old and
young, and even children of five years of age, marched through the streets with
no covering but a scarf round the waist. They each carried a scourge of
leathern thongs, which they applied to their limbs,amid sighs and tears, with Such violence, that the blood flowed from the wounds. Not
only during the day, but even by night, and in the severest winter, they
traversed the cities with burning torches and banners, in thousands and tens of
thousands, headed by their priests, and prostrated themselves before the
altars. They proceeded in the same manner in the villages; and the woods and
mountains resounded with the voices of those whose cries were raised to God.
The melancholy chant of the penitent alone, was heard. Enemies were reconciled;
men and women vied with each other in splendid works of charity, as if they
dreaded, that Divine Omnipotence would pronounce on them the doom of annihilation”.
The pilgrimages of the Flagellants extended throughout
all the provinces of Southern Germany, as far as Saxony, Bohemia and Poland,
and even further; but at length, the priests resisted this dangerous
fanaticism, without being able to extirpate the illusion, which was
advantageous to the hierarchy, as long as it submitted to its sway. Regnier, a hermit of Perugia, is recorded as a fanatic
preacher of penitence, with whom the extravagance, originated. In the year
1296, there was a great procession of the Flagellants in Strasburg and in 1334,
fourteen years before the great mortality, the sermon of Venturinus,
a Dominican friar, of Bergamo, induced above 10,000 persons to undertake a new
pilgrimage. They scourged themselves in the churches, and were entertained in
the market-places at the public expense. At Rome, Venturinus was derided, and banished by the Pope to the mountains of Ricondona.
He patiently endured all—went to the Holy Land, and died at Smyrna, 1346. Hence
we see that this fanaticism was a mania of the middle ages, which, in the year
1349, on so fearful an occasion, and while still so fresh in remembrance,
needed no new founder; of whom, indeed, all the records are silent.
(The pilgrimages of the Flagellants of the year 1349,
were not the last. Later in the 14th century, this fanaticism still manifested
itself several times, though never to so great an extent: in the 15th century,
it was deemed necessary, in several parts of Germany, to extirpate them by fire
and sword;—and in the year 1710, processions of the Cross-bearers were still
seen in Italy. How deep this mania had taken root, is proved by the deposition
of a citizen of Nordhausen (1446): that his wife, in
the belief of performing a Christian act, wanted to scourge her children, as
soon as they were baptized).
It probably arose in many places at the same time; for
the terror of death, which pervaded all nations and suddenly set such powerful
impulses in motion, might easily conjure up the fanaticism of exaggerated and
overpowering, repentance. The manner and proceedings of the Flagellants of the
13th and 14th centuries, exactly resemble each other. But, if during the Black
Plague, simple credulity came to their aid, which seized, as a Consolation, the
grossest delusion of religious enthusiasm, yet it is evident that the leaders
must have been intimately united, and have exercised the power of a secret
association. Besides, the rude band was generally under the control of men of
learning, some of whom at least, certainly had other objects in view,
independent of those which ostensibly appeared. Whoever was desirous of joining
the brotherhood, was bound to remain in it thirty-four days, and to have
four-pence per day at his own disposal, so that he might not be burthensome to
any one; if married, he was obliged to have the sanction of his wife, and give
the assurance that he was reconciled to all men. The Brothers of the
Cross, were not permitted to seek for free quarters, or even to enter a house
without having been invited; they were forbidden to converse with females; and
if they transgressed these rules, or acted without precaution, they were
obliged to confess to the Superior, who sentenced them to several lashes of the
scourge, by way of penance. Ecclesiastics had not, as such, any pre-eminence
among them; according to their original law, which, however, was often
transgressed, they could not become Masters, or take part in the Secret
Councils. Penance was performed twice every day: in the morning and evening,
they went abroad in pairs, singing psalms, amid the ringing of the bells; and
when they arrived at the place of flagellation, they stripped the upper part of
their bodies and put off their shoes, keeping on only a linen dress, reaching
from the waist to the ancles. They then lay down in a large circle, in
different positions, according to the nature of their crime: the adulterer with
his face to the ground; the perjurer on one side, holding up three of his
fingers, and were then castigated, some more and some less, by the Master, who
ordered them to rise in the words of a prescribed form. Upon this, they
scourged themselves, amid the singing of psalms and loud supplications for the
averting of the plague, with genuflexions, and other
ceremonies, of which contemporary writers give various accounts; and at the
same time constantly boasted of their penance, that the blood of their wounds
was mingled with that of the Savior. One of them, in conclusion, stood up to
read a letter, which it was pretended an angel had brought from heaven, to St.
Peter's church, at Jerusalem, stating that Christ, who was sore displeased at
the sins of man, had granted at the intercession of the Holy Virgin and of the
angels, that all who should wander about for thirty-four days and scourge
themselves, should be partakers of the Divine grace. This scene caused as great
a commotion among the believers as the finding of the holy spear once did at
Antioch; and if any among the clergy enquired who had sealed the letter he was
boldly answered, the same who had sealed the Gospel!
All this had so powerful an effect, that the church
was in considerable danger; for the Flagellants gained more credit than the
priests, from whom they so entirely withdrew themselves, that they even
absolved each other. Besides, they everywhere took possession of the churches,
and their new songs, which went from mouth to mouth, operated strongly on the
minds of the people. Great enthusiasm and originally pious feelings, are clearly
distinguishable in these hymns, and especially in the chief psalm of the
Cross-bearers, which is still extant, and which was sung all over Germany, in
different dialects, and is probably of a more ancient date. Degeneracy,
however, soon crept in; crimes were everywhere committed; and there was no
energetic man capable of directing the individual excitement to purer objects,
even had an effectual resistance to the tottering church been at that early
period seasonable, and had it been possible to restrain the fanaticism; The
Flagellants sometimes undertook to make trial of their power of working
miracles; as in Strasburg, where they attempted, in their own circle, to
resuscitate a dead child: they however failed, and their unskilfulness did them much harm, though they succeeded here and there in maintaining some
confidence in their holy calling, by pretending to have the power of casting
out evil spirits.
The Brotherhood of the Cross announced that the
pilgrimage of the Flagellants was to continue for a space of thirty-four years;
and many of the Masters had, doubtless, determined to form a lasting league
against the church; but they had gone too far. Already, in the same year, the
general indignation set bounds to their intrigues; so that the strict measures
adopted by the Emperor Charles IV and Pope Clement who, throughout the whole of
this fearful period, manifested prudence and noble-mindedness, and conducted
himself in a manner every way worthy of his high station, were easily put into
execution. The Sorbonne, at Paris, and the Emperor Charles, had already applied
to the Holy See, for assistance against these formidable and heretical
excesses, which had well nigh destroyed the influence
of the clergy in every place; when a hundred of the Brotherhood of the Cross
arrived at Avignon from Basle, and desired admission.
The Pope, regardless of the intercession of several
cardinals, interdicted their public penance, which he had not authorized; and,
on pain of excommunication prohibited throughout Christendom the continuance of
these pilgrimages. Philip VI, supported by the condemnatory judgment of the
Sorbonne forbid their reception in France. Manfred, King of Sicily, at the
same, time threatened them with punishment by death: and in the East, they were
withstood by several bishops, among whom was Janussius,
of Gnesen, and Preczlaw, of Breslaw,
who condemned to death one of their Masters, formerly a deacon; and, in
conformity with the barbarity of the times, had him publicly burnt. In
Westphalia, where so shortly before, they had venerated the Brothers of the
Cross, they now persecuted them with relentless severity and in the
Mark, as well as in all the other countries of Germany, they pursued them, as
if they had been the authors of every misfortune.
The processions of the Brotherhood of the Cross,
undoubtedly promoted the spreading of the plague; and it is evident, that the
gloomy fanaticism which gave rise to them, would infuse a new poison into the
already desponding minds of the people.
Still, however, all this was within the bounds of
barbarous enthusiasm; but horrible were the persecutions of the Jews, which
were Committed in most countries with even greater exasperation than in the
12th century, during the first Crusades. In every destructive pestilence, the
common people at first attribute the mortality to poison. No instruction
avails; the supposed testimony of their eyesight, is to them a proof, and they
authoritatively demand the victims of their rage. On whom then was it so likely
to fall as on the Jews, the usurers and the strangers who lived at enmity with
the Christians. They were everywhere suspected of having poisoned the wells or
infected the air. They alone were considered as having brought this fearful
mortality among the Christians. They were, in consequence, pursued with
merciless cruelty; and either indiscriminately given up to the fury of the
populace, or sentenced by sanguinary tribunals, which, with all the forms of
law ordered them to be burnt alive. In times like these, much is indeed said of
guilt and innocence; but hatred and revenge bear down all discrimination, and
the smallest probability, magnifies suspicion into certainty. These bloody
scenes, which disgraced Europe in the 14th century, are a counterpart to a
similar mania of the age, which was manifested in the persecutions of witches
and sorcerers; and, like these, they prove, that enthusiasm, associated with
hatred, and leagued with the baser passions, may work more powerfully upon
whole nations, than religion and legal order; nay, that it even knows how to
profit by the authority of both, in order the more surely to satiate with
blood, the sword of long suppressed revenge.
The persecution of the Jews, commenced in September
and October, 1348, at Chillon, on the Lake of Geneva,
where the first criminal proceedings were instituted against them after they
had long before been accused by the people of poisoning the wells; similar
scenes followed in Bern and Freyburg, in January,
1349. Under the influence of excruciating suffering, the tortured Jews
confessed themselves guilty of the crime imputed to them; and it being affirmed
that poison had in fact been found in a well at Zoffingen,
this was deemed a sufficient proof to convince the world; and the persecution
of the abhorred culprits, thus appeared justifiable. Now, though we can take as
little exception at these proceedings, as at the multifarious confessions of
witches, because the interrogatories of the fanatic and sanguinary tribunals,
were so complicated, that by means of the rack, the required answer must
inevitably be obtained; and it is besides conformable to human nature, that
crimes which are in every body's mouth, may, in the end, be actually committed
by some, either from wantonness, revenge, or desperate exasperation: yet crimes
and accusations, are, under circumstances like these, merely the offspring of a
revengeful, frenzied, spirit in the people; and the accusers, according to the
fundamental principles of morality, which are the same in every age, are the
more guilty transgressors.
Already in the autumn of 1348, a dreadful panic,
caused by the supposed poisoning, seized all nations; and in Germany
especially, the springs and wells were built over, that nobody might drink of
them, or employ the water for culinary purposes; and for a long time, the
inhabitants of numerous towns and villages, used only river and rain water. The
city gates were also guarded with the greatest
caution,—only confidential persons were admitted; and if medicine, or any other
article, which might be supposed to be poisonous, was found in the possession
of a stranger,—and it was natural that softie should have these things by them
for their private use,—they were forced to swallow a portion of it. By this
trying state of privation, distrust and suspicion, the hatred against the
supposed poisoners, became greatly increased, and often broke out in popular
commotions, which only served still further to infuriate the wildest passions.
The noble and the mean, fearlessly bound themselves by an oath, to extirpate
the Jews by fire and sword, and to snatch them from their protectors, of whom
the number was so small, that throughout all Germany, but few places can be
mentioned where these unfortunate people were not regarded as outlaws—martyred
and burnt. Solemn summonses were issued from Bern to the towns of Basle, Freyburg in the Breisgau, and Strasburg, to pursue the Jews
as poisoners. The Burgomasters and Senators, indeed, opposed this requisition;
but in Basle the populace obliged them to bind themselves by an oath, to burn
the Jews, and to forbid persons of that community from entering their city, for
the space of two hundred years. Upon this, all the Jews in Basle, whose number
could not have been inconsiderable, were enclosed in a wooden building, constructed
for the purpose, and burnt together with it, upon the mere outcry of the
people, without sentence or trial, which indeed would have availed them
nothing. Soon after, the same thing took place at Freyburg.
A regular Diet was held at Bennefeld, in Alsace,
where the bishops, lords and barons, as also deputies of the counts and towns,
consulted how they should proceed with regard to the Jews; and when the
deputies of Strasburg—not indeed the bishop of this town, who proved himself a
violent fanatic—spoke in favor of the persecuted, as nothing criminal was
substantiated against them; a great outcry was raised, and it was vehemently
asked, why, if so, they had covered their wells and removed their buckets? A
sanguinary decree was resolved upon, of which the populace, who obeyed the call
of the nobles and superior clergy, became but the too willing executioners.
Wherever the Jews were not burnt, they were at least banished; and so being
compelled to wander about, they fell into the hands of the country people, who
without humanity, and regardless of all laws, persecuted them with fire and
sword. At Spires, the Jews, driven to despair, assembled in their own
habitations, which they set on fire, and thus consumed themselves with their
families. The few that remained, were forced to submit to baptism; while
the dead bodies of the murdered, which lay about the streets, were put into
empty wine casks, and rolled into the Rhine, lest they should infect the air.
The mob was forbidden to enter the ruins of the habitations that were burnt in
the Jewish quarter; for the senate itself caused search to be made for the
treasure, which is said to have been very considerable. At Strasburg, two
thousand Jews were burnt alive in their own burial ground, where a large
scaffold had been erected: a few who promised to embrace Christianity, were
spared, and their children taken from the pile. The youth and beauty of several
females also excited some commiseration; and they were snatched from death
against their will: many, however, who forcibly made their escape from the
flames, were murdered in the streets. The senate ordered all pledges and bonds
to be returned to the debtors, and divided the money among the work-people.
Many, however, refused to accept the base price of blood, and, indignant at the
scenes of blood-thirsty avarice, which made the infuriated multitude forget
that the plague was raging around them, presented it to monasteries, in
conformity with the advice of their confessors. In all the countries on the
Rhine, these cruelties continued to be perpetrated during the succeeding
months; and after quiet was in some degree restored, the people thought to
render an acceptable service to God, by taking the bricks of the destroyed
dwellings, and the tombstones of the Jews, to repair churches and to erect belfreys. In Mayence alone,
12,000 Jews are said to have been put to a cruel death. The Flagellants entered
that place in August; the Jews, on this occasion, fell out with the Christians,
and killed several; but when they saw their inability to withstand the
increasing superiority of their enemies, and that nothing could save them from
destruction, they consumed themselves and their families, by setting fire to
their dwellings. Thus also, in other places, the entry of the Flagellants gave
rise to scenes of slaughter; and as thirst for blood was everywhere combined
with an unbridled spirit of proselytism, a fanatic zeal arose among the Jews,
to perish as martyrs to their ancient religion. And how was it possible, that
they could from the heart embrace Christianity, when its precepts were never
more outrageously violated? At Eslingen, the whole
Jewish community burned themselves in their synagogue; and mothers were often
seen throwing their children on the pile, to prevent their being baptized, and
then precipitating themselves into the flames. In short, whatever deeds,
fanaticism, revenge, avarice and desperation, in fearful combination, could
instigate mankind to perform,—and where in such a case is the limit?—were
executed in the year 1349, throughout Germany, Italy and France, with impunity
and in the eyes of all the world. It seemed as if the plague gave rise to
scandalous acts and frantic tumults, not to mourning and grief: and the greater
part of those who, by their education and rank, were called upon to raise the
voice of reason, themselves led on the savage mob to murder and to plunder.
Almost all the Jews who saved their lives by baptism, were afterwards burnt at
different times; for they continued to be accused of poisoning the water and
the air. Christians also, whom philanthropy or gain had induced to offer them
protection, were put on the rack and executed with them. Many Jews who had
embraced Christianity, repented of their apostasy,—and, returning to their
former faith, sealed it with their death.
The humanity and prudence of Clement VI, must, on this
occasion, also be mentioned to his honor; but even the highest ecclesiastical
power was insufficient to restrain the unbridled fury of the people. He not
only protected the Jews at Avignon, as far as lay in his power, but also issued
two bulls, in which he declared them innocent; and admonished all Christians,
though without success, to cease from such groundless persecutions. The Emperor
Charles IV was also favorable to them, and sought to avert their destruction,
wherever he could; but he dared not draw the sword of justice, and even found
himself obliged to yield to the selfishness of the Bohemian nobles, who were
unwilling to forego so favorable an opportunity of releasing themselves from
their Jewish creditors, under favor of an imperial mandate. Duke Albert of
Austria burned and pillaged those of his cities which had persecuted the Jews—a
vain and inhuman proceeding, which, moreover, is not exempt from the suspicion
of covetousness; yet he was unable, in his own fortress of Kyberg,
to protect some hundreds of Jews, who had been received there, from being
barbarously burnt by the inhabitants. Several other princes and
counts, among whom was Ruprecht von der Pfalz, took the Jews under their
protection, on the payment of large sums: in consequence of which they were
called “Jew-masters”, and were in danger of being attacked by the populace and
by their powerful neighbours. These persecuted and ill-used people, except
indeed where humane individuals took compassion on them at their own peril, or
when they could command riches to purchase protection, had no place of refuge
left but the distant country of Lithuania, where Boleslav V, Duke of Poland (1227-1279), had before granted them liberty of conscience;
and King Casimir the Great (1333-1370), yielding to the entreaties of Esther, a
favorite Jewess, received them, and granted them further protection: on which
account, that country is still inhabited by a great number of Jews, who by
their secluded habits, have, more than any people in Europe, retained the
manners of the middle ages.
But to return to the fearful accusations against the
Jews: it was reported in all Europe, that they were in connection with secret
superiors in Toledo, to whose decrees they were subject, and from whom they had
received commands respecting the coining of base money, poisoning, the murder
of Christian children, &c.; that they received the poison by sea from
remote parts, and also prepared it themselves from spiders, owls and other
venomous animals; but, in order that their secret might not be discovered, that
it was known only to their Rabbis and rich men. Apparently there were but few
who did not consider this extravagant accusation well founded; indeed, in many
writings of the 14th century, we find great acrimony with regard to the
suspected poison-mixers, which plainly demonstrates the prejudice existing
against them. Unhappily, after the confessions of the first victims in
Switzerland, the rack extorted similar ones in various places. Some even
acknowledged having received poisonous powder in bags, and injunctions from
Toledo, by secret messengers. Bags of this description, were also often found
in wells, though it was not infrequently discovered that the Christians
themselves had thrown them in; probably to give occasion to murder and pillage;
similar instances of which may be found in the persecutions of the witches.
This picture needs no additions. A lively image of the
Black Plague, and of the moral evil which followed in its train, will vividly
represent itself to him who is acquainted with nature and the constitution of
society. Almost the only credible accounts of the manner of living, and of the
ruin which occurred in private life, during this pestilence, are from Italy;
and these may enable us to form a just estimate of the general state of
families in Europe, taking into consideration what is peculiar in the manners
of each country.
“When the evil had become universal”, (speaking of
Florence) “the hearts of all the inhabitants were closed to feelings of
humanity. They fled from the sick and all that belonged to them, hoping by
these means to save themselves. Others shut themselves up in their houses, with
their wives, their children and households, living on the most costly food, but
carefully avoiding all excess. None were allowed access to them; no
intelligence of death or sickness was permitted to reach their ear; and they
spent their time in singing and music, and other pastimes. Others, on the contrary,
considered eating and drinking to excess, amusements of all descriptions, the
indulgence of every gratification, and an indifference to what was passing
around them, as the best medicine, and acted accordingly. They wandered day and
night, from one tavern to another, and feasted without moderation or bounds. In
this way they endeavored to avoid all contact with the sick, and abandoned
their houses and property to chance, like men whose death-knell had already
tolled. Amid this general lamentation and woe, the influence and authority of
every law, human and divine, vanished. Most of those who were in office, had
been carried off by the plague, or lay sick, or had lost so many
members of their families, that they were unable to attend to their duties;
so that thenceforth every one acted as he thought proper. Others, in their mode
of living, chose a middle course. They ate and drank what they pleased, and
walked abroad, carrying odoriferous flowers, herbs or spices, which they smelt
to from time to time, in order to invigorate the brain, and to avert the
baneful influence of the air, infected by the sick, and by the innumerable
corpses of those who had died of the plague. Others carried their precaution
still further, and thought the surest way to escape death was by flight. They
therefore left the city; women as well men abandoning their dwellings and their
relations, and retiring into the country. But of these also, many were parried
off, most of them alone and deserted by all the world, themselves having
previously set the example. Thus it was, that one citizen fled from another—a
neighbor from his neighbors—a relation from his relations;—and in the end, so
completely had terror extinguished every kindlier feeling, that the brother
forsook the brother—the sister the sister—the wife her husband; and at last,
even this parent his own offspring, and abandoned them, unvisited and unsoothed, to their fate. Those, therefore, that stood in
need of assistance fell a prey to greedy attendants; who for an exorbitant
recompense merely handed the sick their food and medicine, remained with them
in their last moments, and then, not infrequently, became themselves victims to
their avarice and lived not to enjoy their extorted gain. Propriety and decorum
were extinguished among the helpless sick. Females of rank seemed to forget
their natural bashfulness, and committed the care of their persons,
indiscriminately, to men and women of the lowest order. No longer were women,
relatives or friends, found in the house of mourning, to share the grief of the
survivors—no longer was the corpse accompanied to the grave by neighbors and a
numerous train of priests, carrying wax tapers and singing psalms, nor was it
borne along by other citizens of equal rank. Many breathed their last without a
friend to sooth their dying pillow; and few indeed were they who departed amid
the lamentations and tears of their friends and kindred. Instead of sorrow and
mourning, appeared indifference, frivolity and mirth this being considered,
especially by the females, as conducive to health. Seldom was the body followed
by even ten or twelve attendants; and instead of the usual bearers and sextons,
mercenaries of the lowest of the populace undertook the office for the sake of
gain; and accompanied by only a few priests, and often without a single taper,
it was borne to the very nearest church, and lowered into the first grave that
was not already too full to receive it. Among the middling classes, and
especially among the poor, the misery was still greater. Poverty or
negligence induced most of these to remain in their dwellings, or in
the immediate neighborhood; and thus they fell by thousands; and many ended
their lives in the streets, by day and by night. The stench of putrefying corpses
was often the first indication to their neighbors that more deaths had
occurred. The survivors, to preserve themselves from infection, generally had
the bodies taken out of the houses, and laid before the doors; where the early
morn found them in heaps, exposed to the affrighted gaze of the passing
stranger. It was no longer possible to have a bier for every corpse,—three or
four were generally laid together—husband and wife, father and mother, with two
or three children, were frequently borne to the grave on the same bier; and it
often happened that two priests would accompany a coffin, bearing the cross
before it, and be joined on the way by several other funerals; so that instead
of one, there were five or six bodies for interment.
Thus far Boccacio. On the
conduct of the priests, another contemporary observes: “In large and small
towns, they had withdrawn themselves through fear, leaving the performance of
ecclesiastical duties to the few who were found courageous and faithful enough
to undertake them”. But we ought not on tha account
to throw more blame on them than on others; for we find proofs of the same
timidity and heartlessness in every class.& During the prevalence of the
Black Plague the charitable orders conducted themselves admirably, and did as
much good as can be done by individual bodies, in times of great misery and
destruction; when compassion, courage, and the nobler feelings, are found but
in the few,—while cowardice, selfishness and ill-will, with the baser passions
in their train—assert the supremacy. In place of virtue which had been driven
from the earth, wickedness everywhere reared her rebellious standard, and
succeeding generations were consigned to the dominion of her baleful tyranny.
CHAPTER VI.
Physicians.
If we now turn to the medical talent which encountered
the “Great Mortality” the middle ages must stand excused since even the moderns
are of opinion that the art of medicine is not able to cope with the Oriental
plague, and can afford deliverance from it only under particularly favorable
circumstances. We must bear in mind also, that human science and art, appear
particularly weak in great pestilences, because they have to contend with the
powers of nature, of which they have no knowledge; and which, if they had been,
or could be comprehended in their collective effects, would remain
uncontrollable by them, principally on account of the disordered condition of
human society. Moreover, every new plague has its peculiarities, which are the
less easily discovered on first view, because, during its ravages, fear and
consternation humble the proud spirit.
The physicians of the 14th century, during the Black
Death, did what human intellect could do in the actual condition of the healing
art; and their knowledge of the disease was by no means despicable. They, like
the rest of mankind, have indulged in prejudices, and defended them perhaps,
with too much obstinacy: some of these, however, were founded in the mode of
thinking of the age, and passed current in those days, as established truths:
others continue to exist to the present hour.
Their successors in the 19th century; ought not
therefore to vaunt too highly the pre-eminence of their knowledge, for they too
will be subjected to the severe judgment of posterity—they too, will, with
reason, be accused of human weakness and want of foresight.
The medical faculty of Paris, the most celebrated of
the 14th century, were commissioned to deliver their opinion on the causes of
the Black Plague, together with some appropriate regulations with regard to
living, during its prevalence. This document is sufficiently remarkable to find
a place here.
“We, the Members of the College of Physicians, of
Paris, have, after mature consideration and consultation on the present
mortality, collected the advice of our old masters in the art, and intend to
make known the causes of this pestilence, more clearly than could be done
according to the rules and principles of astrology and natural science; we,
therefore, declare as follows:
“It is known that in India, and the vicinity of the
Great Sea, the constellations which combated the rays of the sun, and the
warmth of the heavenly fire, exerted their power especially against that sea,
and struggled violently with its waters. Hence, vapors often originate which
envelope the sun, and convert his light into darkness. These vapors alternately
rose and fell for twenty-eight days; but at last, sun and fire acted so
powerfully upon the sea, that they attracted a great portion of it to
themselves, and the waters of the ocean arose in the form of vapor; thereby the
waters were in some parts, so corrupted, that the fish which they contained,
died. Those corrupted waters, however, the heat of the sun could not consume,
neither could other wholesome water, hail or snow, and dew, originate there
from. On the contrary, this vapor spread itself through& the air in many
places on the earth, and enveloped them in fog.
“Such was the case all over Arabia, in a part of
India; in Crete; in the plains and valleys of Macedonia, in Hungary; Albania
and Sicily. Should the same thing occur in Sardinia, not a man will be left
alive; and the like will continue, so long as the sun remains in the sign of
Leo, on all the islands and adjoining countries to which this corrupted sea-wind
extends, or has already extended from India. If the inhabitants of those parts
do not employ and adhere to the following, or similar means and precepts, we
announce to them inevitable death — except the grace of Christ preserve
their lives.
“We are of opinion, that the constellations, with the
aid of Nature, strive, by virtue of their divine might, to protect and heal the
human race; and to this end, in union with the rays of the sun, acting through
the power of fire, endeavor to break through the mist. Accordingly, within the
next ten days, and until the 17th of the ensuing month of July, this mist will
be converted into a stinking deleterious rain, whereby the air will be much
purified. Now, as soon as this rain announces itself, by thunder or hail, every
one of you should protect himself from the air; and, as well before as after
the rain, kindle a large fire of vine-wood, green laurel, or other green wood;
wormwood and chamomile should also be burnt in great quantity in the market
places, in other densely inhabited localities, and in the houses. Until the
earth is again completely dry, and for three days afterwards, no one ought to
go abroad in the fields. During this time the diet should be simple, and people
should be cautious in avoiding exposure in the cool of the evening, at night,
and in the morning. Poultry and water-fowl, young pork, old beef, and fat meat,
in general, should not be eaten; but on the contrary, meat of a proper age, of
a warm and dry nature, by no means, however, heating and exciting. Broth should
be taken, seasoned with ground pepper, ginger and cloves, especially by those
who are accustomed to live temperately, and are yet choice in their diet.
Sleep in the day-time is detrimental; it should be taken at night until sunrise,
or somewhat longer. At breakfast, one should drink little supper should be
taken an hour before sunset, when more may be drunk than in the morning. Clear
light wine, mixed with a fifth or sixth part of water, should be used as a
beverage. Dried or fresh fruits with wine are not injurious; but highly so
without it. Beet-root and other vegetables, whether eaten pickled or fresh, are
hurtful; on the contrary, spicy pot-herbs, as sage or rosemary, are wholesome.
Cold, moist, watery food is, in general, prejudicial. Going out at night, and
even until three o'clock in the morning, is dangerous, on account of
the dew. Only small river fish should be used. Too much exercise is hurtful.
The body should be kept warmer than usual, and thus protected from moisture and
cold. Rain-water must not be employed in cooking, and everyone
should guard against exposure to wet weather. If it rain, a
little fine treacle should be taken after dinner. Fat people should not sit in
the sunshine. Good clear wine should be selected and drunk often, but in small
quantities, by day. Olive-oil, as an article of food, is fatal. Equally
injurious are fasting or excessive abstemiousness, anxiety of mind, anger, and
excessive drinking. Young people, in autumn especially, must abstain from all these
things, if they do not wish to run a risk of dying of dysentery. In order to
keep the body properly open, an enema, or some other simple means, should be
employed, when necessary. Bathing is injurious. Men must preserve chastity as
they value their lives. Everyone should impress this on his recollection, but
especially those who reside on the coast, or upon an island into which the
noxious wind has penetrated”.
On what occasion these strange precepts were delivered
can no longer be ascertained, even if it were an object to know it. It must be
acknowledged, however, that they do not redound to the credit either of the
faculty of Paris, or of the 14th century in general. This famous faculty found
themselves under the painful necessity of being wise at command and of firing a
point blank shot of erudition at an enemy who enveloped himself in a dark mist,
of the nature of which they had no conception. In concealing their ignorance by
authoritative assertions, they suffered themselves, therefore, to be misled;
and while endeavoring to appear to the world with éclat, only betrayed to the
intelligent their lamentable weakness. Now some might suppose, that in the
condition of the sciences in the 14th century, no intelligent physicians
existed; but this is altogether at variance with the laws of human advancement,
and is contradicted by history. The real knowledge of an age, is only shown in
the archives of its literature. Men of talent here alone deposit the results of
their experience and reflection, without vanity or a selfish object: here alone
the genius of truth speaks audibly. There is no ground for believing that, in
the 14th century, men of this kind were publicly questioned regarding their
views; and it is, therefore, the more necessary that impartial history should
take up their cause and do justice to their merits.
The first notice on this subject is due to a very
celebrated teacher in Perugia, Gentilis of Foligno, who, on the 18th of June, 1348, fell a sacrifice
to the plague, in the faithful discharge of his duty. Attached to Arabian
doctrines, and to the universally respected Galen, he, in common with all his
contemporaries, believed in a putrid corruption of the blood in the lungs and
in the heart, which was occasioned by the pestilential atmosphere, and was
forthwith communicated to the whole body. He thought, therefore, that
everything depended upon a sufficient purification of the air, by means of
large blazing fires of odoriferous wood, in the vicinity of the healthy, as
well as of the sick, and also upon an appropriate manner of living; so that the
putridity might not overpower the diseased. In conformity with notions derived
from the ancients, he depended upon bleeding and purging, at the commencement
of the attack, for the purpose of purification; ordered the healthy to wash
themselves frequently with vinegar or wine, to sprinkle their dwellings with
vinegar, and to smell often to camphor, or other volatile substances. Hereupon
he gave, after the Arabian fashion, detailed rules, with an abundance of
different medicines, of whose healing powers wonderful things were believed. He
laid little stress upon super-lunar influences, so far as respected the malady
itself; on which account, he did not enter into the great controversies of the
astrologers, but always kept in view, as an object of medical attention, the
corruption of the blood in the lungs and heart. He believed in a progressive
infection from country to country, according to the notions of the present day;
and the contagious power of the disease, even in the vicinity of those affected
by plague, was, in his opinion, beyond all doubt. On this point, intelligent
contemporaries were all agreed; and in truth, it required no great genius to be
convinced of so palpable a fact. Besides, correct notions of contagion have descended
from remote antiquity, and were maintained unchanged in the 14th
century. So far back, as the age of Plato, a knowledge of the contagious
power of malignant inflammations of the eye, of which also no physician of the
middle ages entertained a doubt, was general among the people; yet, in modern
times, surgeons have filled volumes with partial controversies on this subject.
The whole language of antiquity has adapted itself to the notions of the
people, respecting the contagion of pestilential diseases; and their terms
were, beyond comparison, more expressive than those in use among the moderns.
Arrangements for the protection of the healthy
against contagious diseases, the necessity of which is shown from
these notions, were regarded by the ancients as useful; and by many, whose
circumstances permitted it, were carried into effect in their houses. Even a
total separation of the sick from the. healthy, that indispensable means of
protection against infection by contact, was proposed by physicians of the 2nd
century after Christ, in order to check the spreading of leprosy. But it was
decidedly opposed because as it was alleged, the healing art
ought not to be guilty of such harshness. This mildness of the ancients, in
whose manner of thinking inhumanity was so often and so undisguisedly
conspicuous might excite surprise if it were anything more than apparent. The
true ground of the neglect of public protection against pestilential diseases,
lay in the general notion and constitution of human society,— it lay in the
disregard of human life, of which the great nations of antiquity have given
proofs in every page of their history. Let it not be supposed that they wanted
knowledge respecting the propagation of contagious diseases. On the contrary,
they were as well informed on this subject as the moderns; but this was shown
where individual property, not where human life, on the grand scale, was to be
protected. Hence the ancients made a general practice of arresting the progress
of murrains among cattle, by a separation of the diseased from the healthy.
Their herds alone enjoyed that protection which they held it impracticable to
extend to human society, because they had no wish to do so. That the
governments in the 14th century, were not yet so far advanced, as to put into
practice general regulations for checking the plague, needs no especial proof.
Physicians could, therefore, only advise public purifications of the air by
means of large fires, as had often been practiced in ancient times; and they
were obliged to leave it to individual families, either to seek safety in
flight, or to shut themselves up in their dwellings, a method which answers in
common plagues, but which here afforded no complete security, because such was
the fury of the, disease when it was at its height, that the atmosphere of
whole cities was penetrated by the infection.
Of the astral influence which was considered to have
originated the “Great Mortality”, physicians and learned men were as
completely convinced as of the fact of its reality. A grand conjunction of the
three superior planets, Saturn, Jupiter and Mars, in the sign of Aquarius, which
took place according to Guy de Chauliac, on the 24th
of March, 1345, was generally received as its principal cause. In fixing the
day, this physician, who was deeply versed in astrology, did not agree with
others; whereupon there arose various disputations, of weight in that age, but
of none in ours; people, however, agreed in this—that conjunctions of the
planets infallibly prognosticated great events; great revolutions of kingdoms,
new prophets, destructive plagues, and other occurrences which bring distress
and horror on mankind. No medical author of the 14th and 15th century, omits an
opportunity of representing them as among the general prognostics of great
plagues; nor can we, for our parts, regard the astrology of the middle ages, as
a mere offspring of superstition. It has not only, in common with all ideas
which inspire and guide mankind, a high historical importance, entirely
independent of, its error or truth—for the influence of both is equally
powerful—but there are also contained in it, as in alchemy, grand thoughts of
antiquity, of which modern natural philosophy is so little ashamed that she
claims them as her property. Foremost among these, is the idea of the general
life which diffuses itself throughout the whole universe, expressed by the
greatest Greek sages, and transmitted to the middle ages, through the new
Platonic natural philosophy. To this impression of an universal organism, the
assumption of a reciprocal influence of terrestrial bodies could not be
foreign, nor did this cease to correspond with a higher view of nature, until
astrologers overstepped the limits of human knowledge with frivolous and
mystical calculations.
Guy de Chauliac, considers
the influence of the conjunction, which was held to be all-potent, as the chief
general cause of the Black Plague; the diseased state of bodies, the corruption
of the fluids, debility, obstruction, and so forth, as the especial subordinate
causes. By these, according to his opinion, the quality of the air, and of the
other elements, was so altered, that they set poisonous fluids in motion
towards the inward parts of the body, in the same manner as the magnet attracts
iron; whence there arose in the commencement fever and the spitting of blood;
afterwards, however, a deposition in the form of glandular swellings and
inflammatory boils. Herein the notion of an epidemic constitution was set
forth, clearly and conformably, to the spirit of the age. Of contagion,
Guy de Chauliac was completely convinced. He sought
to protect himself against it by the usual means; and it was probably he who
advised Pope Clement VI to shut himself up while the plague lasted. The
preservation of this pope's life, however, was most beneficial to the city of
Avignon, for he loaded the poor with judicious acts of kindness,—took care to
have proper attendants provided, and paid physicians himself to afford
assistance wherever human aid could avail; an advantage which, perhaps, no
other city enjoyed. Nor was the treatment of plague patients in Avignon by any
means objectionable; for, after the usual depletions by bleeding and aperients,
where circumstances required them, they endeavored to bring the buboes to
suppuration; they made incisions into the inflammatory boils, or burned them
with a red-hot iron, a practice which at all times proves salutary, and in the
Black Plague saved many lives. In this city the Jews, who lived in a state of
the greatest filth, were most severely visited, as also the Spaniards, whom Chalin accuses of great intemperance.*
Still more distinct notions on the causes of the
plague were stated to his contemporaries in the 14th century, by Galeazzo di
Santa Sofia, a learned man, a native of Padua, who likewise treated
plague-patients at Vienna, though in what year is undetermined. He
distinguishes carefully pestilence from epidemic and endemic. The common notion
of the two first accords exactly with that of an epidemic constitution, for
both consist, according to him, in an unknown change or corruption of the air;
with this difference, that pestilence calls forth diseases of different kinds;
epidemic, on the contrary, always the same disease. As an example of an
epidemic, he adduces a cough which was observed in all climates at the same
time, without perceptible cause; but he recognized the approach of a pestilence
independently of unusual natural phenomena, by the more frequent occurrence of
various kinds of fever, to which the modern physicians would assign a nervous
and putrid character. The endemic originates, according to him, only in local
telluric changes—in deleterious influences which develop themselves in the
earth and in the water, without a corruption of the air. These notions were
variously jumbled together in his time, like everything which human
understanding separates by too fine a line of limitation. The estimation of
cosmical influences, however, in the epidemic and pestilence, is well worthy of
commendation; and Santa Sofia, in this respect, not only agrees with the most
intelligent persons of the 14th and 15th centuries, but he has also promulgated
an opinion which must, even now, serve as a foundation for our scarcely
commenced investigations into cosmical influences. Pestilence and epidemic,
consist, not in alterations of the four primary qualities, but in a corruption
of the air, powerful, though quite immaterial and not cognoscible by the
senses: in a disproportion of the imponderables in the atmosphere as it would
be expressed by the moderns.
The causes of the pestilence and epidemic are, first
of all, astral influences, especially on occasion of planetary conjunctions;
then extensive putrefaction of animal and vegetable bodies, and terrestrial
corruptions; to which also, bad diet and want may contribute. Santa Sofia
considers the putrefaction of locusts, that had perished in the sea, and were
again thrown up, combined with astral and terrestrial influences, as the cause
of the pestilence in the eventful year of the “Great Mortality”.
All the fevers which were called forth by the
pestilence are, according to him, of the putrid kind; for they originate
principally from putridity of the heart's blood, which inevitably follows the
inhalation of infected air. The Oriental Plague is, sometimes, but by no means
always, occasioned by pestilence (?), which imparts to it a character hostile
to human nature. It originates frequently from other causes, among which, this
physician was aware that contagion was to be reckoned; and it deserves to be
remarked, that he held epidemic small-pox and measles to be infallible
forerunners of the plague, as do the physicians and people of the East at the
present day.
In the exposition of his therapeutical views of the
plague, a clearness of intellect is again shown by Santa Sofia, which reflects
credit on the age. It seemed to him to depend, 1st, on an evacuation of putrid
matters, by purgatives and bleeding: yet he did not sanction the employment of
these means indiscriminately, and without consideration; least of all where the
condition of the blood was healthy. He also declared himself decidedly against
bleeding ad deliquium. 2d, Strengthening of the heart and
prevention of putrescence. 3d, Appropriate regimen. 4th, Improvement of the
air. 5th, Appropriate treatment of tumid glands and inflammatory boils, with
emollient, or even stimulating poultices (mustard, lily-bulbs), as well as with
red-hot gold and iron. Lastly, 6th, Attention to prominent symptoms. The stores
of the Arabian pharmacy, which he brought into action to meet all these
indications, were indeed very considerable; it is to be observed, however, that,
for the most part, gentle means were accumulated, which in case of abuse, would
do no harm; for the character of the Arabian system of medicine, whose principles were everywhere followed at this time, was
mildness and caution. On this account too, we cannot believe that a very prolix
treatise by Marsigli di Santa Sofia, a contemporary
relative of Galeazzo, on the prevention and treatment of plague, can have
caused much harm, although, perhaps, even in the 14th century, an agreeable
latitude and confident assertions respecting things which no mortal has
investigated, or which it is quite a matter of indifference to distinguish,
were considered as proofs of a valuable practical talent.
The agreement of contemporary and later writers, shows
that the published views of the most celebrated physicians of the 14th century,
were those generally adopted. Among these, Chalin de Vinario is the most experienced. Though devoted to
astrology, still more than his distinguished contemporary, he acknowledges the
great power of terrestrial influences, and expresses himself very sensibly on
the indisputable doctrine of contagion, endeavoring thereby to apologize for
many surgeons and physicians of his time, who neglected their duty. He asserted
boldly, and with truth, “that all epidemic diseases might become contagious
and all fevers epidemic” which attentive observers of all subsequent ages
have confirmed.
He delivered his sentiments on bloodletting with
sagacity, as an experienced physician; yet he was unable, as may be imagined,
to moderate the desire for bleeding shown by the ignorant monks. He was averse
to draw blood from the veins of patients under fourteen years of age; but
counteracted inflammatory excitement in them by cupping; and endeavored to
moderate the inflammation of the tumid glands by leeches. Most of those who
were bled, died; he therefore reserved this remedy for the plethoric;
especially for the papal courtiers, and the hypocritical priests, whom he saw
gratifying their sensual desires, and imitating Epicurus, whilst they pompously
pretended to follow Christ. He recom- mended
burning the boils with a red-hot iron, only in the plague without fever, which
occurred in single cases; and was always ready to correct those over-hasty
surgeons, who, with fire and violent remedies, did irremediable injury to their
patients. Michael Savonarola, professor in Ferrara (1462), reasoning on the
susceptibility of the human frame to the influence of pestilential infection,
as the cause of such various modifications of disease, expresses himself as a
modern physician would on this point; and an adoption of the principle of
contagion, was the foundation of his definition of the plague. No less worthy
of observation are the views of the celebrated Valescus of Taranta, who, during the final visitation of the
Black Death, in 1382, practiced as a physician at Montpellier, and handed down
to posterity what has been repeated in innumerable treatises on plague, which
were written during the 15th and 16th centuries.
Of all these notions and views regarding the plague,
whose development we have represented, there are two especially, which are
prominent in historical importance:—1st, The opinion of learned physicians,
that the pestilence, or epidemic constitution, is the parent of various kinds
of disease; that the plague sometimes, indeed, but by no means always,
originates from it: that, to speak in the language of the moderns, the
pestilence bears the same relation to contagion, that a predisposing cause does
to an occasional cause: and 2dly, the universal conviction of the contagious
power of that disease.
Contagion gradually attracted more notice: it was
thought that in it, the most powerful occasional cause might be avoided; the
possibility of protecting whole cities by separation, became gradually more
evident; and so horrifying was the recollection of the eventful year of the
“Great Mortality”, that before the close of the 14th century, ere the ill
effects of the Black Plague had ceased, nations endeavored to guard against the
return of this enemy, by an earnest and effectual defence.
The first regulation which was issued for this
purpose, originated with Viscount Bernabo, and is
dated the 17th Jan. 1374. “Every plague patient was to be taken out of the city
into the fields, there to die or to recover. Those who attended upon a plague
patient, were to remain apart for ten days, before they again associated with
anybody. The priests were to examine the diseased, and point out to special
commissioners, the persons infected; under punishment of the confiscation of
their goods, and of being burned alive. Whoever imported the plague, the state
condemned his goods to confiscation. Finally, none except those who were
appointed for that purpose, were to attend plague-patients, under penalty of
death and confiscation”.
These orders, in correspondence with the spirit of the
14th century, are sufficiently decided to indicate a recollection of the good
effects of confinement, and of keeping at a distance those suspected of having
plague. It was said that Milan itself, by a rigorous barricado of three houses in which the plague had broken out, maintained itself free from
the “Great Mortality” for a considerable time; and examples of the preservation
of individual families, by means of a strict separation, were certainly very
frequent. That these orders must have caused universal affliction from their
uncommon severity, as we know to have been especially the case in the city of
Reggio, may be easily conceived; but Bernabo did not
suffer himself to be frightened from his purpose—on the contrary, when the
plague returned, in the year 1383, he forbad the admission of people from
infected places into his territories, on pain of death. We have now, it is
true, no account how far he succeeded; yet it is to be supposed that he
arrested the disease, for it had long lost the property of the Black Death, to
spread abroad in the air the contagious matter which proceeded from the lungs,
charged with putridity, and to taint the atmosphere of whole cities by the
vast numbers of the sick. Now that it had resumed its milder form, so that it
infected only by contact, it admitted being confined within individual
dwellings, as easily as in modern times.
Bernabo’s example was imitated; nor was there any
century more appropriate for recommending to governments strong regulations
against the plague, than the 14th; for when it broke out in Italy, in the year
1399, and still demanded new victims, it was for the 16thtime; without
reckoning frequent visitations of measles and small-pox. In this same year,
Viscount John, in milder terms than his predecessor, ordered that no stranger
should be admitted from infected places, and that the city gates should be
strictly guarded. Infected houses were to be ventilated for at least eight or ten
days, and purified from noxious vapors by fires, and by fumigations with
balsamic and aromatic substances. Straw, rags, and the like, were to
be burned; and the bedsteads which had been used, set out for four days in
the rain or the sunshine, so that, by means of the one or the other, the
morbific vapor might be destroyed. No one was to venture to make use of clothes
or beds out of infected dwellings, unless they had been previously washed and
dried either at the fire or in the sun. People were, likewise, to avoid, as
long as possible, occupying houses which had been frequented by plague-patients.
We cannot precisely perceive in these an advance
towards general regulations; and perhaps people were convinced of the
insurmountable impediments which opposed the separation of open inland
countries, where bodies of people connected together could not be brought, even
by the most obdurate severity, to renounce the habit of a profitable
intercourse.
Doubtless it is Nature which has done the most to
banish the Oriental plague from western Europe, where the increasing
cultivation of the earth, and the advancing order in civilized society,
prevented it from remaining domesticated; which it most probably had been in
the more ancient times.
In the fifteenth century, during which it broke out
seventeen times in different places in Europe, it was of the more consequence
to oppose a barrier to its entrance from Asia, Africa, and Greece (which had
become Turkish); for it would have been difficult for it to maintain itself
indigenously any longer. Among the southern commercial states, however, which
were called on to make the greatest exertions to this end, it was principally
Venice, formerly so severely attacked by the black plague, that put the
necessary restraint upon the perilous profits of the merchant. Until towards
the end of the fifteenth century, the very considerable intercourse with the
East was free and unimpeded. Ships of commercial cities had often brought over
the plague: nay, the former irruption of the great mortality itself bad been
occasioned by navigators. For, as in the latter end of Autumn, 1347, four ships
full of plague-patients returned from the Levant to Genoa, the disease spread
itself there with astonishing rapidity. On this account, in the following year,
the Genoese forbid the entrance of suspected ships into their port. These
sailed to Pisa and other cities on the coast, where already Nature had made
such mighty preparations for the reception of the Black Plague, and what we
have already described took place in consequence.
In the year 1485, when, among the cities of northern
Italy, Milan especially felt the scourge of the plague, a special council of
health, consisting of three nobles, was established at Venice, who probably
tried everything in their power to prevent the entrance of this disease, and
gradually called into activity all those regulations which have served in
later times as a pattern for the other southern states of Europe. Their
endeavors were, however, not crowned with complete success; on which account
their powers were increased, in the year 1504, by granting them the right of
life and death over those who violated the regulations. Bills of health were
probably first introduced in the year 1527, during a fatal plague which Visited
Italy for five years (1525—30), and called forth redoubled caution.
The first lazarettos were established upon islands at
some distance from the city, seemingly as early as the year 1485. Here all
strangers coming from places where the existence of plague was suspected were
detained. If it appeared in the city itself, the sick were despatched with their families to what was called the Old Lazaretto, were there furnished
with provisions and medicines, and, when they were cured, were detained,
together with all those who had had intercourse with them, still forty days
longer in the New Lazaretto, situated on another island. All these
regulations were every year improved, and their needful rigor was increased, so
that from the year 1585 onwards no appeal was allowed: from the sentence of the
Council of Health; and the other commercial nations gradually came to the
support of the Venetians, by adopting corresponding regulations Bills of
health, however, were not general until the year 1665.
The appointment of a forty days’ detention, whence
quarantines derive their name, was not dictated by caprice, but probably had a
medical origin, which is derivable in part from the doctrine of critical days;
for the fortieth day, according to the most ancient notions, has been always
regarded as the last of ardent diseases, and the limit of separation between
these and those which are chronic. It was the custom to subject lying in women
for forty days to a more exact superintendence. There was a good deal also said
in medical works of forty day epochs in the formation of the foetus, not to mention that the alchemists expected more
durable revolutions in forty days, which period they called the philosophical
month.
This period being generally held to prevail in natural
processes, it appeared reasonable to assume and legally to establish it as that
required for the development of latent principles of contagion, since public
regulations cannot dispense with decisions of this kind, even though they
should not be wholly justified by the nature of the case. Great stress has
likewise been laid on theological and legal grounds which were certainly of
greater weight in the fifteenth century than in more modern times.
On this matter, however, we cannot decide, since our
only object here is to point out the origin of a political means of protection
against a disease, which has been the greatest impediment to civilization
within the memory of man; a means, that, like Jenner’s vaccine after the
small-pox had ravaged Europe for twelve hundred years, has diminished the check
which mortality puts on the progress of civilization, and thus given to the
life and manners of the nations of this part of the world a new direction, the
result of which we cannot foretell.
|